By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Better sales: Metal Gear 4 or Smash Brothers Brawl? Opinions?

Yeah, like them above said... Brawl. No contest.



Nintendo Network ID: Cheebee   3DS Code: 2320 - 6113 - 9046

 

Around the Network
Oyvoyvoyv said:
@Desroko

We have already said that, why did you re-post it?

Because the OP insists on blaming the VGC numbers, when they are clearly not at fault. I'm trying to pound into is head that he made a mistake.



ZenfoldorVGI said:
it's the biggest Nintendo franchise.

...after wii ___, mario kart and pokemon

Bets:Missed by 420k I bet leo-j vg$500 that wii will sell 31 million by 7/31/08.  Sorry, I don't think he has enough vg$ to make it with all of u that wish you could. Hit, with room to spare I bet kingofwale a 1-week ban that wii Americas ltd sales>360 Americas ltd sales as of the numbers for week ending 7/05/08 (using vgchartz homepage #s)

Predictions:

Wii will sell 18-20mil by 12/31/07  CHECKWii will sell 45mil+ WW by 12/31/08Wii will surpass PS2 sales WW by 11/17/11 (5yr anniversary)Wii Fit will hit 12mil sales in 2009MKWii+SSBB+Wii Fit+SMG > 50 mil sales by 2010 > gta4+mgs+gt5+ff13+haze+lbp
rasone77 said:
Iam sure that the data said all for both. I checked it multiple times. I think some other people also said that the Melee data was off but I didn't think it was off by that much..

u are wrong check again

Bets:Missed by 420k I bet leo-j vg$500 that wii will sell 31 million by 7/31/08.  Sorry, I don't think he has enough vg$ to make it with all of u that wish you could. Hit, with room to spare I bet kingofwale a 1-week ban that wii Americas ltd sales>360 Americas ltd sales as of the numbers for week ending 7/05/08 (using vgchartz homepage #s)

Predictions:

Wii will sell 18-20mil by 12/31/07  CHECKWii will sell 45mil+ WW by 12/31/08Wii will surpass PS2 sales WW by 11/17/11 (5yr anniversary)Wii Fit will hit 12mil sales in 2009MKWii+SSBB+Wii Fit+SMG > 50 mil sales by 2010 > gta4+mgs+gt5+ff13+haze+lbp

MGS2 + MGS2:Substance sold around 7 million WW, and MGS3 + MGS3: Subsistence sold close to 5 and is still selling, albeit slowly. Melee sold over 7 million if I recall correctly.

Given those numbers, and given the sales of the Wii and PS3, then Brawl's sales may as much as double MGS4's.



Around the Network
Desroko said:
Oyvoyvoyv said:
@Desroko

We have already said that, why did you re-post it?

Because the OP insists on blaming the VGC numbers, when they are clearly not at fault. I'm trying to pound into is head that he made a mistake.


Pound this into your head. I looked here not at the game data itself:

http://vgchartz.com/swlaunch.php?reg1=All&game1=Super+Smash+Bros+Melee+-+GC&reg2=All&game2=Metal+Gear+Solid+3%3A+Snake+Eater+-+PS2&reg3=All&game3=&weeks=400

See anything wrong here?

-Edited by moderator 



dumb question. Brawl is a type of game that needs to be compared to the likes of Final Fantasy, GT and GTA not MGS.
MGS can sell shitloads but SSBB sells more shitloads.



I'd say Brawl sales may even get to 2.5-3 times MGS4 sales if PS3 doesn't improve its performance.



In Memoriam RVW Jr.

SSBB Friend Code = 5455-9050-8670 (PM me if you add so I can add you!) 

Tetris Party Friend Code = 116129046416 (ditto)

ssbb of course. it has the biger fan base for now.

but mgs4 will end up selling a lot because " its the only "good" exclusive for ps3"



Oyvoyvoyv said:
For a comparison of Japan:

N64 Smash: 1.9M - 49th best selling game in Japan ever.

Melee: 1.4M - 82nd best selling game in Japan ever.

Brawl: 1.5M - 67th best selling game in Japan ever.

MGS 2: 844K - 187th best selling game in Japan ever.

MGS 3: 815K - 193rd best

MGS 1: 780K

And PS3 has 1/13 of the userbase of the PS2, and it won't increase to more than 1/5 probably.
You mean to tell me that the PS3 will not sell more than 25 million consoles? Wow.....