FishyJoe said: Does anyone wonder why Sony or MS haven't copied Wii Play? Seems it would be a simple matter to create some mini-game or demo, perhaps even a platinum title, to include with a controller and charge a couple bucks more. Is it pride or something? GT5P would have seemed like the perfect time to adopt this strategy. |
Funny you should ask Fishy, I made a post on gamespot a while back discussing the exact same thing. The answer is simple:
A. Nintendo games sell well. Microsoft and Sony games don't have the same brand name for software sales.
B. PS3 and 360 aren't systems that require multiple controllers. Many, many owners, only have one control, and all their multiplayer is online. Therefore, controller sales are less than the Wii.
C. Wii play sells off the software as well as the hardwares percieved value. Many Wii owners, view a minigame collection as an increased value. PS3 and 360 owners might not.
D. Controllers, are all expensive, including the Wiimote. However, early on, the Wiimote was supply constrained, and many people were forced to buy Wii-play to get the remote. To repeat this success, MS and Sony would have to create manufactured supply constraints, which wouldn't be viewed very favorably.
E. Once controllers are in the store, there is no getting them back. If Sony-Play failed, those remotes would go unsold. There is a risk with releasing software bundles with such little profit potential per unit.
The model could work for MS or Sony, but its far from free money, and I can definately see it failing, considering the userbase your selling too.
That said, the best time for Sony to do this is with the release of the new Duel Shock. To be successful, all of the DS controllers should be packaged without a larger pricetag, and a cheap game made by sony.
It just doesn't seem like their style. Not that Sony doesn't milk the consumers, just that they don't like to immediately and obviously copy a more successful company, because then they couldn't release PR statements being eliteist pricks about it.