Ryuu96 said:
Angelus said:
Killing them wasn't a mistake at all. Their deaths brought some actual emotional stakes to the table, that would have otherwise been absent. You just don't like it because you're not fond of the new supporting cast, but that's not Bungie's problem.
|
Disagree, killing them was a mistake and even moreso because of how awful their deaths are but that'll happen if you think you have to kill somebody simply because it's the last game, maybe if their deaths actually had any emotional impact but they didn't, their deaths felt rushed and were done poorly, it didn't make me think Chief was at risk and it didn't surprise me that an emotionally unstable AI betrayed us at the time.
Makes it even worse when you learn Johnson is a Spartan I and he went out like such a chump also learning he's immune to the flood could have been an interesting plot device explored in a later Halo game when the flood return.
I'm fine with Miranda dying but her death was awful too.
|
Johnson's death was a bit cheap, but Miranda's was just fine imo. And no, their deaths didn't make me think Chief was any more at risk, but the fact is, some people of import on your side had to die. You can't just keep saying humanity is on it's last leg, and everything is fucked, and talk about all the high stakes, but never actually kill anyone that people care about. That said, neither character was super important to me personally, but hey it's something at least. So ya....I was ok with them dying. I would have been more annoyed if everyone made it out alive.
You should be happy they didn't kill Arbiter, Chief, or Cortana. Without those, 343 would have had some actual problems.
And none of that stuff you just brought up about Johnson was explored or laid bare in the games at all. So ya sure, you can act like he was super interesting and had all this stuff going for him, but in game he was just an amusing, cocky, drill seargeant type. I was annoyed, and a bit sad he died, but the way he was presented and utitlized throughout the trilogy was replacable as hell, so killing him isn't gimping 343 in the slightest imo