Gears 3> Gears 1> Halo 3> Gears 2>>>>> All other Halos>>>>>>>> Gears Judgement.

I don't really like either of them, but I'd probably go with Gears. They both have bullet sponge enemies, and I kinda hate that.

Definitely Halo.

Gears 2 > Gears 1 > Gears 3 >>>>> Halo 2 > Halo 1 > Halo 4 > Halo 3 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gears Judment > Halo Reach

Gears all day. That type of shooter is more up my ally. An up-in-your-face gory shooter entices my preferences more than Halo. However, I will always have a special place in my heart for Halo. I'll be getting both when they release. :)

Gears easily. A game made for men.

I think that's a hard choice for me. I like gears for horde but i like halo for its multiplayer and forge mode. Sigh... I miss forging

Not all that different initially, and cleary the original Gears trilogy have a massive upper hand on our lists....... perhaps its because i played Halo 3 first that i rate it the highest out of the Halos, and doing the campaign on Legendary with 3 freinds back in the day were some of my best memories on xbox live.

Will agree that Reach was a dissapiontment, and no surprises to see Judgement so far down on your list too..... the campaign was just about passable, but the multiplayer modes were absolute rubbish IMO.

The people have spoken, Gears sucks!

Now is better. :P