By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Will we ever see another game with a 95+ metascore?

 

Can game ratings be as high as before?

Sure, we'll see other ga... 144 86.75%
 
No, no other game will ev... 13 7.83%
 
Maybe for some new IPs, b... 9 5.42%
 
Total:166

Some say it's because reviewers were too generous last gen and are overcompensanting this gen, others think it's because they're too old/on this job for far too long, and are burnt out. Whatever the case, it's undeniable that review scores are faaaaar lower, and critics are MUCH harsher with games.

So here's the question, will we ever see another game with insanely high scores? I mean, Mario 3D World was 93, which is excellent of course. But then you have Mario Galaxy and Galaxy 2, GTA 5, all of which were 97. Uncharted 2 is 96, The Last of Us is 95... Will we ever see something like that again? I mean, it feels like games like Second Son or Sunset Overdrive or Shadow of Mordor would have scored higher had they been released earlier, but none of them reached a 90 metascore. I even doubt the scores for estabilished franchises and developers at this point (despite Mario 3D World) - can the next God of War or Uncharted 4, or even Zelda U reach the heights of their predecessors?

 

Here's a disclaimer for ya: I'm not saying reviews are that important, it's just an interesting question I thought here.

 

Edit: sorry for the poll there... wasn't aware it was gonna cut words like that, and I can't edit it =P



Around the Network

Probably...I just don't think it will happen unless a game does something new



Yeah we probably will. I'm sure GTA VI will get higher than 95 and there's a good chance something like Uncharted 4 and a Legend of Zelda could as well.



Something this year will do it

Most likely Zelda U



The Last of Us Re-Remastered



Around the Network

I am pretty certain we will. Specially in 2015



                  

PC Specs: CPU: 7800X3D || GPU: Strix 4090 || RAM: 32GB DDR5 6000 || Main SSD: WD 2TB SN850

Most console Zelda games score above 95. The only one that didn't was Skyward Sword, and that had unconventional controls that knocked it down a couple points. I definitely think Zelda U will bounce back.

Others that have a shot include, but are not limited to, Xenoblade Chronicles X (original scored 92), Uncharted 4, Final Fantasy XV and...wow, I can't really think of anything else that has a huge chance.



Official Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Thread

                                      

I'm thinking Final Fantasy XV....



Yes, Zelda this year :P



Skullwaker said:
Most console Zelda games score above 95. The only one that didn't was Skyward Sword, and that had unconventional controls that knocked it down a couple points. I definitely think Zelda U will bounce back.

Others that have a shot include, but are not limited to, Xenoblade Chronicles X (original scored 92), Uncharted 4, Final Fantasy XV and...wow, I can't really think of anything else that has a huge chance.

Batman Arkham Knight and MGSV.