Oh okay, you win. I guess all of the 2m+ buyers are all so very disappointed with their pointless purchase of a universally acclaimed game on their PS4.

See my first post that is cut off from this quote tree.

Wind Waker HD put Wind Waker into my top ten games of all time, but it just didn't sell that many copies. :(

TLOU > MCC >>> Wind Waker.

Wind waker takes it away!!!! 

I loved replaying Windwaker and it has the best visual upgrade. The artwork and rendering style scales up beautifully.
The last of us was awesome to replay as well. The added photo mode was a lot of fun to play with.
I never bothered to finish Halo CE or Halo 2 I don't feel like replaying them either. Halo 4 was OK, but Halo is just not a favorite of mine.


That said, Windwaker will sell the least and didn't do much for the WiiU either.
TLoU probably has done more for ps4 than Halo MCC does for XB1. There's more people switching from 360 to ps4 after all.
Which will sell more in the end, probably depends on how long either will be bundled...


Windwaker is the best remaster, not a single glitch found by me.
Then TLoU. I had a few graphical glitches while it was still installing and I managed to crash it once in photo mode.
Halo MCC, seems to be on the way to be as bad as DC launch, although I read there are plenty offline glitches too which DC doesn't have. At least they didn't promise a free version...


Best value, Halo MCC when it works.
Then TLoU, goty edition including DLC for discounted price.
Last Windwaker, they actually made the game shorter! (I like sailing dammit)

Well then it's not pointless.

1. Halo Master Chief Collection.
2. The Last of Us: Remastered.
3. Halo Master Chief Collection.
4. Halo Master Chief Collection.

I think MCC has this one in the bag overall. It will sell extremely well due to a strong fan base, and also have long legs. The remake of Halo 2 and quality of Halo 4's graphics are of amazing quality and the overall package... well, no competition really :).

MCC by a long shot(I doo not like Halo FYI).

3) TLOU:R is a year old game and while ND is highly regarded, a new ND game would do so much for visibility. The game brings next to nothing new(other than 1080p/60) to the table compared to its PS3 brother

2) ZWW while an older game isnt really a pinnacle of Zelda games and I would say the Zelda fanbase has a very mixed view on how good it is in comparison to others of the series. OOT or MM would be more appropriate for a remaster(though Ninty did those on 3DS for some reason). This game also doesnt bring much new to the table(Widescreen, 720p/60, touchpad integration). I rank it above TLOU:R only due to the game getting more new features as well as the game being not widely available.

1) MCC has one major selling point in that it offers something that the other 2 dont. Halo 2 multiplayer is probably the most important game in the beginnings of online console FPS. For everyone without lan buddies Halo 2 online was gone forever. Anyone who has fond memories of that game will be buying an X1. Ironically the multiplayer is broken but the game still brings people to look into an X1 based on it offering an(nostalgic) experience not available anywhere else. There are visual(texture)/rez/fps upgrades to Halo 2 as well.

LTD:TLOU(bundle and eventual PS+)

Biggest visual upgrade: MCC

Best value:MCC

1-Halo
2-Halo
3-Wind Waker
4-Halo