By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Should I sell my XB1 and get a PS4?

I guess Oz is PlayStation land so you'll find a lot more people online on the PS4.  What do your friends have?  If you switch and they're all on the other network then that won't be good either.



My 8th gen collection

Around the Network
starcraft said:
daredevil.shark said:
Get a PS4. Xbox One is great but PS4 offers a much differentiated gaming experience. From regular COD, anime, JRPG, awesome first party games to charming games like little big planet are only in PS4.

You just recommended a series of things the PS4 doesn't have...yet?




Nate4Drake said:
Don't know what to say. If you can only afford one Console, and you are not a super Hot Halo fan, you might switch to PS4, where you have the better multiplatform games, and more variety in the 1st Party games.



My 8th gen collection

TheAdjustmentBureau said:
only777 said:
TheAdjustmentBureau said:
Only thing I would say is it sounds like Phil Spencer is putting time and money into rare classics like banjo and conker


Microsoft already pissed over Banjo, I very much doubt anyone with any working brain cells would be happy to see them do it again.


Phil Spencer is in charge now. Things are already a lot better. And he knows what he is doing. Microsoft have already started the gen well with exclusives. Sony is struggling outside indie games which can be found on pc and tablets. Apart from a last gen game which reviewers used last gen scores for Xbox is winning at retail exclusives. With no answer to horizon 2 or titanfall atm.

 

The order is also getting bad press. Another exclusive that could meta low 70s or high 60s. If sunset overdrive reviews well 85+ then Xbox is going strong. It's difficult to know what halo mcc will score, but like gran turismo it will sell regardless of score.

 

I believe Phil Spencer will put a proper team together for a banjo 3 and new conker. He's doing wonders at the moment. As a Nintendo gamer there is much more promise for Xbox than ps.

 


Just stop.  What on earth has Phil Spencer done in the past to earn this respect?

During the 360 from launch until 2008 he worked with Lionhead and rare.  The first made increasingly worse Fable games until the studio founder left and rare utterly collapased in quality.  Viva, Banjo Nut and Bolts and Kinect Sports - all utter shit.

After which he became head of Microsoft Studios whos original content decinded and dwinded to the point that they only had about 1 game in 2012.

I have no idea what good will Phil has built up with you to put such a huge amount of faith in him, but I think It's mis-placed.



Depends if you want to play the Xbox exclusives or not. I personally wouldn't sell any console as you get ripped off and i might want to play it later. PS4 is a good buy though



Xbox Series, PS5 and Switch (+ Many Retro Consoles)

'When the people are being beaten with a stick, they are not much happier if it is called the people's stick'- Mikhail Bakunin

Prediction: Switch 2 will outsell the PS5 by 2030

Around the Network
only777 said:
.


Just stop.  What on earth has Phil Spencer done in the past to earn this respect?

During the 360 from launch until 2008 he worked with Lionhead and rare.  The first made increasingly worse Fable games until the studio founder left and rare utterly collapased in quality.  Viva, Banjo Nut and Bolts and Kinect Sports - all utter shit.

After which he became head of Microsoft Studios whos original content decinded and dwinded to the point that they only had about 1 game in 2012.

I have no idea what good will Phil has built up with you to put such a huge amount of faith in him, but I think It's mis-placed.

I think Phil Spancer is more like a good PR guy , but as a Business decision maker he's carier is just started. So we will have to wait is Phils  good or bad for Xbox Division.



I don't know about this, it's up to you.



ICStats said:
Nate4Drake said:
Don't know what to say. If you can only afford one Console, and you are not a super Hot Halo fan, you might switch to PS4, where you have the better multiplatform games, and more variety in the 1st Party games.

I suddenly find myself becoming an Xbox fanboy...




Get Your Portable ID!Lord of Ratchet and Clank

Duke of Playstation Plus

Warden of Platformers

only777 said:
TheAdjustmentBureau said:
only777 said:
TheAdjustmentBureau said:
Only thing I would say is it sounds like Phil Spencer is putting time and money into rare classics like banjo and conker


Microsoft already pissed over Banjo, I very much doubt anyone with any working brain cells would be happy to see them do it again.


Phil Spencer is in charge now. Things are already a lot better. And he knows what he is doing. Microsoft have already started the gen well with exclusives. Sony is struggling outside indie games which can be found on pc and tablets. Apart from a last gen game which reviewers used last gen scores for Xbox is winning at retail exclusives. With no answer to horizon 2 or titanfall atm.

 

The order is also getting bad press. Another exclusive that could meta low 70s or high 60s. If sunset overdrive reviews well 85+ then Xbox is going strong. It's difficult to know what halo mcc will score, but like gran turismo it will sell regardless of score.

 

I believe Phil Spencer will put a proper team together for a banjo 3 and new conker. He's doing wonders at the moment. As a Nintendo gamer there is much more promise for Xbox than ps.

 


Just stop.  What on earth has Phil Spencer done in the past to earn this respect?

During the 360 from launch until 2008 he worked with Lionhead and rare.  The first made increasingly worse Fable games until the studio founder left and rare utterly collapased in quality.  Viva, Banjo Nut and Bolts and Kinect Sports - all utter shit.

After which he became head of Microsoft Studios whos original content decinded and dwinded to the point that they only had about 1 game in 2012.

I have no idea what good will Phil has built up with you to put such a huge amount of faith in him, but I think It's mis-placed.


He wasn't behind Microsoft studios dwindling. That was a direction don matrick took the Xbox division as a whole.

 

Since he's been head of Xbox, he's done nothing but good things. Listening to gamers and giving us what we want. As head of Xbox I have no reason he won't continue in the same fashion. He's even listened to the gamers about parity clause. So all those Indies will likely head to Xbox. He's done a tremendous job.



AkimboCurly said:
Short Answer: No.

Long Answer: Based on your priorities you need to consider 3 things.
1. CoD advanced warfare has more preorders for Xbox One than any other platform. Hence, it is logical to assume that the largest player base will be there. There is also the early DLC for xbox platforms, and platform parity.
2. Exclusive Games. There aren't any great PS4 exclusive games. If you weren't able to fall in love with Gears, Halo, Titanfall, Forza Horizons, Left 4 Dead, or the future prospects of Sunset Overdrive, Halo 5, Quantum Break, Scalebound or Crackdown, then you won't fall in love with Playstations breif collection (of Infamous and DriveClub).
3. Timing. Xbox One is just getting warmed up at this stage, with a constant supply of exclusives for the forseeable future. PS4 doesn't get any more notable AAA exclusive games until the end of 2015 (with Uncharted 4, and Bloodborne), in fact, no more are arrving this year.

You have to ask yourself why you are buying it. The only reason would be a graphical upgrade. I respect any decision you choose, so long as you have fun, but do consider these points.

In terms of the OP, I would actually recommend at least waiting til the CoD:AW release, see how the sales pan out on both sides, and be prepared to make the switch quickly within the first week. I would ask that the OP not consider the above points, though, because the above points are actually really, really poorly constructed. o.o

1. I have no particular opinion either way about this. xP Pre-order numbers could result in a higher player base on Xbox One, but then, there's the higher PS4 install base to consider; which way the penduluum swings, we shall see. Which is why I recommended you, Mister OP, wait til release, see where the initial sales fall, etc, etc, if CoD is your driving motivation.

2. Given the gentleman above was listing games that haven't been released yet, (basically the second half of his list,) and games that haven't been revealed beyond a meaningless CGI-trailer, with little concrete info, (Scalebound, Gears, Crackdown, Left 4 Dead 3, etc, assuming it stays exclusive this time,) when listing Xbox One titles, I am shocked that he couldn't even be bothered to list all the games that are currently released on the PS4, let alone the ones coming.

Since he so meticulously covered the Xbox One's side, allow me to flesh out the Sony side, using his own parameters, with Infamous, DriveClub, Killzone, (also Bloodborne and Uncharted, though to be fair, he did list them in point 3,) God of War, Ratchet and Clank, Infamous, The Order, The Tomorrow Children, Until Dawn, quirkier or smaller Sony titles like Tearaway Unfolded, Little Big Planet, Rime, Resogun, Alienation... I'm not even bringing in the non-Sony-partnered Indie exclusives (i.e. the ones that might not come to Xbox One because of the parity clause,) or the more Japanese-centric titles and RPGs that will never see an Xbox platform release, (because it's always tricky to tell just which ones are going to be localized for the Western market.) Or the Free to Play titles either currently on, or on the way, to the console like Planetside 2, Deep Down, War Thunder, Everquest Next, etc.

Now, how much the indies, free to play and Japanese titles matter is, of course, a matter for you to decide personally, but it should still be noted the gap exists. =P

3. Though he did list Bloodborne in point 3, he said 'end of 2015,' which, given Bloodborne and The Order are both slated for a Febuary 2015 release, blasts that part of the argument right out of the water. =D All I can find for the Xbox One is a Q2 release for Quantum Break (if anyone has more up-to-date information, feel free to share,) some visual novels, couple of side-scrolling shoot-em-ups, an unspecified 2015 release for Crackdown (could be end of the year, could be earlier,) and of course Tomb Raider and Halo 5, both of which are, I believe, intended for end-of-year releases?(Again, if there are any meatier titles I missed with solidly estimated 2015 release dates, feel free to share, Internets! :3 )

Now, granted, one might point out 'Well, they probably haven't announced all their games!' and spot on, they probably haven't. But then, the same applies for Sony, so all we have to go on is the existing lineup for now.

One thing I do agree is that Sony doesn't have much left for the end of the year, aside from, I believe, Little Big Planet. ...but on the flip side, look at the number of 3rd party multiplat titles coming out during the holiday season, look at your wallet, and decide how much it bothers you that there's a couple less exclusives on one side than the other this holiday. =P



Zanten, Doer Of The Things

Unless He Forgets In Which Case Zanten, Forgetter Of The Things

Or He Procrascinates, In Which Case Zanten, Doer Of The Things Later

Or It Involves Moving Furniture, in Which Case Zanten, F*** You.