Plus you have to factor in that Destiny had quite a few expensive "editions"

I have nothing against the total estimative, since the sellthrough and average price WW is acceptable (and the sellthrough announced have digital sales as well, that could be anything from 10 to 30%), and with the upgrade plan for free on digital they probably had good sales on it.

But the breaktrough giving exactly the same proportion of total HW isn't a talking point because it isn't that the game have that breakthrough, just that VGC in lack of better precise numbers just gave the aproximate ratio of HW as SW... and that wouldn't make sense since we had the exclusive marketing AND BUNDLE, look at WD for comparison. X1 free SW promotion and their history of shooters on xboxes may offset some of the marketing on PS4, but I don't think it make it basically useless.

X1 undertracked in USA, this week proves it

Um... how does it prove it? o.o I'm not sure whether you're saying either,

1) The given figure for the U.S. this week is an excellent number, and proves the Xbox One sells bunches, so all the other weeks must be undertracked cause they look so meh while the Xbox One sold so wonderfully this week, etc, etc, etc. In which case, I'd have to say, this week indicates nothing, given they were giving out a free game, plus a game bundle, PLUS in some cases that gift certificate, meaning that you could potentially get as much as 150 bucks worth of 'bonus' stuff on top of the console itself.

or,

2) The given figure for U.S. this week is a teeeerrible number, and so this week proves that the Xbox One must be getting undertracked, because the number for the posted week should, in your opinion, be MUCH higher than what it provided. Don't actually have much opinion about that, beyond that I'm kind of surprised it got as close to the PS4's sales that week in the first place, what with all the Destiny preorder bundles getting redeemed that week. =P Free game week or not, I don't think anyone was actually expecting the Xbox One to outsell the PS4 for that week, in the USA or otherwise. PS4's sales boost would have been too large, and too top-heavy, for the X1 to have much of a chance of catching up before week's end.

Either way, you might want to wait for adjustments. o.O The numbers for both the PS4 and Xbox One could end up going down, or up, depending on the NPD results.

Looks overtracked to me...

And PS4 undertracked... I guess Destiny bundle sold more and not just that little.

Holy hell. There's been so many games adjusted up.

GTA V PS3 - 18.55 million

The Last of Us PS3 - 5.04 million

Gran Turismo 6 - 2.79 million

Watch Dogs PS4 - 3.06 million

inFamous: Second Son - 1.78 million

And many more.

Hasn't NPD always proven the opposite?

You've got to be kidding me. Sony lied about sales of TLOU too? Damn them! So the basic formula is: Take anything Sony says and remove 1m ... Got it.

Cool to see some adjustments!

The Last of Us PS3 still remains heavily Undertracked. They announced it 7m in July (shipped+digital). Digital is less than 10% in all games and it's not like the game was just out and a lot of units would have been on shelves, meaning at the time the game was probably at around 6m sold through. And even if it wasn't, it should have achieved it by now.

Got the previous numbers?   I know that Watch Dogs PS4 used to be at about 2.5 million. Also PS4 have it's first 3 million seller! And is now the best selling single plattform game version.( beating Mario Kart 8)