I just wanted to say good game. Also WoW and others say voting for yourself is a bad idea.. usually it is I suppose. However my trap of voting for myself twice managed to catch the entire mafia team day one... I gotta give credit to wright tho killing me was the best thing he did all game. Also theprof don't be so hard on yourself you saw what I was doing for what it was, ya used good logic and ya helped greatly in catching mafia. Imo the score was town 1-1, ghost 2-0, and mafia 0-2. 1 win out of potentially 2 losses is not bad. Also count me in for next mafia game :D.

Aslo @Carl sorry for tunneling you day one. I thought your paranoia and weakish logic day one was a sign you were hiding something. You were, I just thought you were hiding the fact you were the ghost or mafia. I didn't even consider you were a paranoid townie with an important role. Tho it was my second game. So thanks for that learning experience. Thanks WoW and Smeags for hosting. I think town did a good job despite the results. I was still thinking Padib had to be the ghost. Wright played extremely well and as much as town deserved that win Wright deserved it more for fooling everyone into thinking he was the cop especially when there is a confirmed super sherif in game.

how generous of you.

I'm saying you could have tried for helping wright get lynched instead of going full crazy on prof.

only reason you weren't lynched day 3 was because the nuke said you weren't the nuke, had we found him I have no doubt you would have been lynched.

Then, various marines until we found the last scum.

Day 2 the lynch was pretty clearly going to be sparks, TOS killed any chance of it being anyone else.

Day 3 wright "cleared" padib as the nuke, as you say rrhe town focused too much on protoss, we did well leaving padib alone until after the nuke threat.

Day 3 wasn't the town lynching wrong, it was ryan making himself too anoying to the one player who could shut him up for good.

I need to go look at my day one meta list again and see how many were right.

hmm I was 4 for 4 on town TOS White, Hylian and Carl and 1 for 3 on scum wright while not prof and cone.

pretty poor, TOS, prof, and myself wouldn't be satisfied until you were lynched, though you could have tried to work the protos angle on me, there were just too many holes and changes to your story, and after all it was prof's town :P

I never said changing, I said that you built it piece by piece. The feeling I had was that you were making it up as you went along.

Time to reveal my role...

I am Erin's magical pet sheep: Bhaltair.

Anyways, all credit goes to Words of Wisdom, as he was the sole creator of the flavor, set up, and analysis. I was just there to tally votes and gain a unique perspective of watching you all fall over one another.

But yeah, WoW made a pretty incredible twist to the game and it was a blast to watch.

I think a special kudos goes to Carl, who really applied some smart intuition and support to help town. Healed Truck Night 1 when he used the StimPack, healed Truck on Night 2 when attacked, correctly called out Wright as a non-town, correctly called out Padib as Kerrigan. Unfortunately he didn't follow through!

The Lucky's Rabbit Foot award goes to Wright, who somehow... someway... made it to Day 5. His role PM goof, his use of EMP on Padib, Padib's worst case attack on Wright on Night 3 (Seriously, any other combination of Zerg would have killed him )... but at the start of day 5 he stood tall.

You were lucky we didn't click too many times on you :P