By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Carl2291 said:
I dont see how my case against Nick can be used against me, when so many other people also noticed his poor play and questioning his motives/ overall play.

While he did end up being Terran, the cases against him were concrete... It was just poor play on his part that got so many people to suspect him (Ironic, considering my careless/poor play with the l1 is the main case you have against me)


what's the case against sparks?



Around the Network
Carl2291 said:
I dont see how my case against Nick can be used against me, when so many other people also noticed his poor play and questioning his motives/ overall play.

While he did end up being Terran, the cases against him were concrete... It was just poor play on his part that got so many people to suspect him (Ironic, considering my careless/poor play with the l1 is the main case you have against me)


At the bold,

No, not hardly. you're case was flimsy.  you twice used daytalk as an argument, http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6658094, and http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6664738

Making the assumption of an unusual rule hardly makes a concrete case.

Next up, lets break down how those somehow make him scum, the first because his teammates told him to explain his vote, so you accusing of eric and imp of being the scum buddies because its in the next few posts where he replies with them that he does explain more. In fact he's had quite a few posts to make it clear well before you came in to call it a bandwagon, eventually you answer a question and he moves his vote, now claim it's when he was confronted over it it the first post I listed, but he changed it after you answered his question, while that was also after TOS voted him, the vote wasn't about his vote on you.  (The fact that TOS was the one to pop in there is quite interesting, he does seem to do that A LOT)

 

The second is trying to say that his vote on himself was them trying to get sympathy, how do you think that was good strategy to recomend when he wasn't anywhere near that sort of danger? It brought MORE attention to himself.

I've also come to ralize prof was pobably far from joking, he reads way too into this game and knows what scum are more likely to do, all your quotes made it scream mafia.



Carl2291 said:
Wright said:

Then Terran can kill Terran. Essencially, you can't say for sure there's more than one faction.


The Terran PM states directly that Terran = Town and Scum = Non-Terran.

HoS Wright


I hate meta gaming :(your actions make me think scum but there is this...

yeah I could see you warned over that, even killed actually.



EricFabian said:
theprof00 said:

Why has this not been quoted by anyone yet?

white, why would it make more sense for carl to have voted you if he had a daytime scanning role?

pedit i mean eric.


whiteeagle was right and I already said that I was silly at the beginning

that wasn't the point prof was making, he was bringing up that when white made the other assumption of you having a day scanning role, why did he say you'd scan him scum?

that could have been a slip, but then again this is Mr ILLCLAIMIMMAFIABECAUSEIMBORED so I'm thinking it's along the lines of  he didn't think it out well when he posted it.



I shall reply later, after work when I get to a computer.



                            

Around the Network

Wow, i guess everyone else is in wait-and-see mode.

It makes sense. The guy with most suspicion has the most votes right now, and we're almost at the end of Day 2, right? Nobody seems to want to try to push Sparks even to L-2.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

(3) Carl2291 - Mr Khan, WhiteEaglePL, Wonktonodi
(5) Sparks - theprof00, Conegamer, spurgeonryan, Carl2291, TruckOSaurus
(1) theprof00 - Sparks
(1) Wright - padib

(4) Not Voting - EricFabian, radishhead, Wright, impertinence

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Countdown to Night 2: http://itsalmo.st/#night2

Please PM Words of Wisdom or myself if there's an issue with the vote count.



Yeah, the day ends in just 7 hours. 7 hours!

It's time to sorta start posting rather than hanging back. I'm still up for Sparks; he seems like the safest bet right now.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Wonktonodi said:
EricFabian said:
theprof00 said:

Why has this not been quoted by anyone yet?

white, why would it make more sense for carl to have voted you if he had a daytime scanning role?

pedit i mean eric.


whiteeagle was right and I already said that I was silly at the beginning

that wasn't the point prof was making, he was bringing up that when white made the other assumption of you having a day scanning role, why did he say you'd scan him scum?

that could have been a slip, but then again this is Mr ILLCLAIMIMMAFIABECAUSEIMBORED so I'm thinking it's along the lines of  he didn't think it out well when he posted it.

Quote where on earth I even said that...



Very weird how everything has just fallen off the cliff. To experienced players, is this type of situation typical? Is this an indication that the case against Sparks is so strong that no one thinks there's any point in looking for anything else? I am puzzled to say the least, but maybe this is the typical ebb and flow of mafia?

Anyway, Sparks has earned his spot right now, Carl is on the hot seat, but what about a character like EricFabian? He continuous down the same path of fake activity and long stretches of nothing at all. Obviously he is playing since he showed up with more nonsense as soon as he was prodded by WoW.

To me, these days would have been better spent looking for someone else to lynch than Sparks, and if we can't find consensus on another strong lynch go ahead and flip Sparks. I am wondering why this has not happened. Especially prof and Trucks I would have expected to take advantage of the potential great head start we could have gotten. The way I see it we have a strong case on Carl as well, but I'm disappointed in the lack of following up on that. Cone's middle of the road play too, another potential line of questioning that's not been picked up. And of course the case of EricFabian.

If town had applied itself just a little bit, we could have had two scum in the net by now, and possibly strong cases for other players as well.

Oh well, sparks is is I guess. At least then could town come up with some theories of what the Sparks flip will tell us?

I say, if Sparks flips scum, Carl is next in line if Sparks flips town then I would take a good look at Trucks. What say you town? (Scum need not reply)