By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Contradiction: Isn't TLOU:R also giving gamers choice like people argue for EA Access?

 

Are you against remastered games?

Yes 10 10.42%
 
No 45 46.88%
 
Hell Yes 2 2.08%
 
Hell No 30 31.25%
 
nnoooo-yes 2 2.08%
 
yeeees-no 5 5.21%
 
Total:94
jlmurph2 said:
SWORDF1SH said:

"Sony fans would understand why we like EA Access."

Judging by the fact that EA Access is X1 exclusive and you use the term 'we', you are insinuating that comment is on behalf of MS fans.

But the thread isn't anti EA Access anyway, it isn't even pro EA access. It's a pro 'Remastered' thread. Show me where I said anything bad about EA Access. Maybe you should practice what you preach and stop defending EA Access when nobody is attacking it.


@bolded I repeat: NOT ONLY MICROSOFT FANS LIKE THE SERVICE. 

When I say "we like it" it literally means "the people who like it". There are Sony and Nintendo fans that like the service too.

The first words in this thread are literally EA Access. Did you expect me not to talk about it or something? If you try to compare the two in the OP/title then do it right. 

I guess you don't know what insinuate means then. To me your statement was carefully worded just so you can say you like EA Access but try and gain the higher ground by claiming you're a neutral. Out of curiosity, do you own a 360 or X1?

And because I mensioned EA Access, it doesn't mean that you have to defend it when it's not being attacked. I fail to see your logic. Stick to what the thread is about and not assume a product is being attacked just because it's mentioned.



Around the Network
SWORDF1SH said:
jlmurph2 said:
SWORDF1SH said:

"Sony fans would understand why we like EA Access."

Judging by the fact that EA Access is X1 exclusive and you use the term 'we', you are insinuating that comment is on behalf of MS fans.

But the thread isn't anti EA Access anyway, it isn't even pro EA access. It's a pro 'Remastered' thread. Show me where I said anything bad about EA Access. Maybe you should practice what you preach and stop defending EA Access when nobody is attacking it.


@bolded I repeat: NOT ONLY MICROSOFT FANS LIKE THE SERVICE. 

When I say "we like it" it literally means "the people who like it". There are Sony and Nintendo fans that like the service too.

The first words in this thread are literally EA Access. Did you expect me not to talk about it or something? If you try to compare the two in the OP/title then do it right. 

I guess you don't know what insinuate means then. To me your statement was carefully worded just so you can say you like EA Access but try and gain the higher ground by claiming you're a neutral. Out of curiosity, do you own a 360 or X1?

And because I mensioned EA Access, it doesn't mean that you have to defend it when it's not being attacked. I fail to see your logic. Stick to what the thread is about and not assume a product is being attacked just because it's mentioned.


You seriously have no idea what you're talking about. Im done here. Next time if you dont want a subject brought up in a thread, dont put it in the title. 



The publishers can bring on the games.  It doesn't matter if they are remastered or not.  The more choices the better.



What the Whaaaaaaaaa???

for me, tlou:r is in the same category as cod:ghosts, ac4, fifa, tomb raider, rayman legends, on xbo/ps4 and mass efect, batman arkham city and deus ex on wii u.

the game was out before the next gen console was available. the next gen version came after q next gen console went out.
no problems here.

the problem is only nothing between infamous and driveclub.
but im aware ps4 wouldn't be a good deal in it's firts year, like every console.



vkaraujo said:

1-EA is more hated than TLoU:R

2-Part of the "feeling of hate" comes from too many defensive TLoU:R topics being created.

3-There is indeed some hate, some from people that can't play the game.

4-There is a real reason for some hate, since between I:SS and Drive Club, there is only one big game, that many of this early adopters already played. This hate is not against TLoU:R, but against SONY. Some of that is reflecting over the game though.


Well, there was MLB the show 2014 in between.



Around the Network
JayWood2010 said:

Kind of tired of threads about TLoU:R whether it be defensive or criticism. THis is becoming the next TitanFall topic, though not quite that bad.

Correct me if im wrong but i believe people's complaints with TLoU stems from the price more than anything.  YOu know people complained about Tomb Raider's price as well 


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6571771



SWORDF1SH said:
JayWood2010 said:

 


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6571771


What is your point?  It still doesnt fit what people want for the price right?  (From the people complaining)

I think everybody just needs to calm down and realize each other's pov (opinions).  One side is saying its a great game and that people who didnt own a ps3 will enjoy it.  THe other side says it isnt a game they asked for to be remade and that it should be cheaper.  Neirther side is wrong, its your opinion.  If you want it then get it, if you dont, then dont.  But we really dont need to have the same argument weekly when we already know everybody's opinions in the first place, and youre not going to change anybody's mind




       

In all honesty I think you are making a big deal out of nothing. When you are saying "All the hate", it is just some people, the majority do not care at all or actually like re-mastered versions.

And then we have the same issue with EA Access. Some people are just hating it for 2 reasons:
- One is good (while I disagree with it), which is because they believe it will set a precedent and blah blah.
- The second is just, "it is on Xbox One, I'm not an Xbox enthusiast, therefore I should hate it"...

But all in one, the people who are the most impacted by those Remakes/Re-Mastered and Publisher accesses are very happy about it.



jlmurph2 said:


You seriously have no idea what you're talking about. Im done here. Next time if you dont want a subject brought up in a thread, dont put it in the title. 


O come on. Was the thread even attacking EA Access? No, so no need to defend it. People can rightly love or hate EA Access. People have the right to love or hate remastered games. Forums are to discuss opinions on given subject and it's ok to stand your corner and debate your own opinion. The trouble is you came in on the defensive about EA Access. If you want talk about the actual topic then please feel free to explain why one/both is/are good/bad for consumer choice.

You did say something about the remastered games being a cash cow which is a fair point. I can see why people would be worried if lazy remasters were made to just generate extra cash. Me personally  research before I buy but the majority don't.



JayWood2010 said:
SWORDF1SH said:


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6571771


What is your point?  It still doesnt fit what people want for the price right?  (From the people complaining)

I think everybody just needs to calm down and realize each other's pov (opinions).  One side is saying its a great game and that people who didnt own a ps3 will enjoy it.  THe other side says it isnt a game they asked for to be remade and that it should be cheaper.  Neirther side is wrong, its your opinion.  If you want it then get it, if you dont, then dont.  But we really dont need to have the same argument weekly when we already know everybody's opinions in the first place, and youre not going to change anybody's mind

??? This isn't opinion, it's fact. To get the game on PS3 with the DLC is $1 cheaper on Amazon. Maybe you can get one or the other cheaper elsewhere but to keep it simple and easy I used Amazon.

The point? To disprove your comment. The price is around the same price as the PS3 verion. Do you think the PS4 version should be cheaper? Why?

What game are people asking to be remade? Ask 20 people and you will more than likely get 20 different answers. So no matter what remaster they did, somebody wouldn't be happy.