By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - PlayStation 4 GPU Vs Xbox One GPU Vs PC – The Ultimate Benchmark Comparison

WhiteEaglePL said:

Wii U Vita and 3DS should be included anyways imho. and PC clearly has the edge -well......depends on what PC.

Then make a seperate topic about that, but don't bring it in here.

Keep it on topic in this thread. Topic is a benchmark comparsion of the PS4 and Xbox One.



Around the Network

The thing both these consoles have as a plus is optimization, you usually get more out of dedicated gaming machines than a PC. Still, the 8th Gen was kind of obsolete before it even began.



PS4 has a lot of advatages over a 7850 or 7870. It has the 8 ACE / 64 Queues setup only seen on the R9290x. It also has access much more RAM than any variation of the 7850 or 7870 ever did. It is also connected in a way vastly supirior to PCI-E.

The PS4's ability to utilize more memory, comunicate faster CPU GPU, Perform GPGPU operations, and fully utilize every CU in the GPU make it punch above either of those cards, and this even before the improved development enviornment.

Anyone that thinks their GTX 660/760 or 7850/7870 is going to outperform PS4 for a long time to come will be in for a surprise. Not saying they won't be able to play the game, just they won't be able to reach PS4 level graphics on multiplats in the next year or so.



Stop hate, let others live the life they were given. Everyone has their problems, and no one should have to feel ashamed for the way they were born. Be proud of who you are, encourage others to be proud of themselves. Learn, research, absorb everything around you. Nothing is meaningless, a purpose is placed on everything no matter how you perceive it. Discover how to love, and share that love with everything that you encounter. Help make existence a beautiful thing.

Kevyn B Grams
10/03/2010 

KBG29 on PSN&XBL

KBG29 said:
PS4 has a lot of advatages over a 7850 or 7870. It has the 8 ACE / 64 Queues setup only seen on the R9290x. It also has access much more RAM than any variation of the 7850 or 7870 ever did. It is also connected in a way vastly supirior to PCI-E.

The PS4's ability to utilize more memory, comunicate faster CPU <-> GPU, Perform GPGPU operations, and fully utilize every CU in the GPU make it punch above either of those cards, and this even before the improved development enviornment.

Anyone that thinks their GTX 660/760 or 7850/7870 is going to outperform PS4 for a long time to come will be in for a surprise. Not saying they won't be able to play the game, just they won't be able to reach PS4 level graphics on multiplats in the next year or so.


Agree



KBG29 said:
PS4 has a lot of advatages over a 7850 or 7870. It has the 8 ACE / 64 Queues setup only seen on the R9290x. It also has access much more RAM than any variation of the 7850 or 7870 ever did. It is also connected in a way vastly supirior to PCI-E.

The PS4's ability to utilize more memory, comunicate faster CPU <-> GPU, Perform GPGPU operations, and fully utilize every CU in the GPU make it punch above either of those cards, and this even before the improved development enviornment.

Anyone that thinks their GTX 660/760 or 7850/7870 is going to outperform PS4 for a long time to come will be in for a surprise. Not saying they won't be able to play the game, just they won't be able to reach PS4 level graphics on multiplats in the next year or so.

The 760 is already better than the PS4 architecture. Graphics cards all have dedicated 2-3 GBs DDR5 memory, which keeps them up to speed for the most part with the PS4, and core for core Intel PC processors have a huge advantage over performing tasks than the PS4's 8 cores do. Just because the PS4's GPU has access to a bit more "dedicated" memory, doesn't change the fact that the real-world performance is equivalent to relatively weak mid-end cards.

The reason I put "dedicated" in quotations is because it really isn't dedicated for the graphics. The RAM is shared with the CPU, which eliminates a good portion of it in actual use (and with only 5.5 GB available for game use, that could be a serious issue). With PC, the graphics card always has access to 2-3 GB DDR5 of dedicated memory, and then the system has 8 GB DDR3 more for the CPU to utilize.



                                                                                                               You're Gonna Carry That Weight.

Xbox One - PS4 - Wii U - PC

Around the Network

damn why did i spend $399AUD on a PS4 last night.....



 

 

VanceIX said:
KBG29 said:
PS4 has a lot of advatages over a 7850 or 7870. It has the 8 ACE / 64 Queues setup only seen on the R9290x. It also has access much more RAM than any variation of the 7850 or 7870 ever did. It is also connected in a way vastly supirior to PCI-E.

The PS4's ability to utilize more memory, comunicate faster CPU <-> GPU, Perform GPGPU operations, and fully utilize every CU in the GPU make it punch above either of those cards, and this even before the improved development enviornment.

Anyone that thinks their GTX 660/760 or 7850/7870 is going to outperform PS4 for a long time to come will be in for a surprise. Not saying they won't be able to play the game, just they won't be able to reach PS4 level graphics on multiplats in the next year or so.

The 760 is already better than the PS4 architecture. Graphics cards all have dedicated 2-3 GBs DDR5 memory, which keeps them up to speed for the most part with the PS4, and core for core Intel PC processors have a huge advantage over performing tasks than the PS4's 8 cores do. Just because the PS4's GPU has access to a bit more "dedicated" memory, doesn't change the fact that the real-world performance is equivalent to relatively weak mid-end cards.

WThe reason I put "dedicated" in quotations is because it really isn't dedicated for the graphics. The RAM is shared with the CPU, which eliminates a good portion of it in actual use (and with only 5.5 GB available for game use, that could be a serious issue). With PC, the graphics card always has access to 2-3 GB DDR5 of dedicated memory, and then the system has 8 GB DDR3 more for the CPU to utilize.

Yes new Card will be better but what KGB29 Said still hold true. I have a state of the art PC , but still love Vita :). 



the-pi-guy said:
$200 is entry level?
And second of all, the fact that we can get a better GPU for a "few hundred dollars more" is so ridiculous to bring up. Why did they even bother?


No, $200 is considered the start of the high end.  $75 is entry level.  It goes:

$0-$60 = Common user.

$60-$100 = Entry

$100 - $200 = Mid Range

$200 - $300 = High End

$300 - $600 = Enthusiast

$600+ = Insane!



krippaz said:
VanceIX said:
KBG29 said:
PS4 has a lot of advatages over a 7850 or 7870. It has the 8 ACE / 64 Queues setup only seen on the R9290x. It also has access much more RAM than any variation of the 7850 or 7870 ever did. It is also connected in a way vastly supirior to PCI-E.

The PS4's ability to utilize more memory, comunicate faster CPU <-> GPU, Perform GPGPU operations, and fully utilize every CU in the GPU make it punch above either of those cards, and this even before the improved development enviornment.

Anyone that thinks their GTX 660/760 or 7850/7870 is going to outperform PS4 for a long time to come will be in for a surprise. Not saying they won't be able to play the game, just they won't be able to reach PS4 level graphics on multiplats in the next year or so.

The 760 is already better than the PS4 architecture. Graphics cards all have dedicated 2-3 GBs DDR5 memory, which keeps them up to speed for the most part with the PS4, and core for core Intel PC processors have a huge advantage over performing tasks than the PS4's 8 cores do. Just because the PS4's GPU has access to a bit more "dedicated" memory, doesn't change the fact that the real-world performance is equivalent to relatively weak mid-end cards.

WThe reason I put "dedicated" in quotations is because it really isn't dedicated for the graphics. The RAM is shared with the CPU, which eliminates a good portion of it in actual use (and with only 5.5 GB available for game use, that could be a serious issue). With PC, the graphics card always has access to 2-3 GB DDR5 of dedicated memory, and then the system has 8 GB DDR3 more for the CPU to utilize.

Yes new Card will be better but what KGB29 Said still hold true. I have a state of the art PC , but still love Vita :). 

His comment about memory utilization was wrong though. The PS4's GPU has no access to dedicated RAM, it shares 5.5 GB with the CPU, so it doesn't have much more available RAM at any point than the 760 in actual gameplay. 

In the real world, the difference between the PCI-E setup and the PS4's direct setup is relatively negligible overall, as seen by all these different tests which show it only managing to keep pace with the 7850, not above it.



                                                                                                               You're Gonna Carry That Weight.

Xbox One - PS4 - Wii U - PC

the-pi-guy said:
VanceIX said:

His comment about memory utilization was wrong though. The PS4's GPU has no access to dedicated RAM, it shares 5.5 GB with the CPU, so it doesn't have much more available RAM at any point than the 760 in actual gameplay. 

In the real world, the difference between the PCI-E setup and the PS4's direct setup is relatively negligible overall, as seen by all these different tests which show it only managing to keep pace with the 7850, not above it.

Dedicated RAM was a bad point for the PS3.  And he didn't say anything about "dedicated."  The Last of Us wasn't even run on a full 512 MB of RAM.  

Consoles also have optimization to help.  

He said it has access to "much more RAM", which isn't true, since it has no dedicated RAM. And dedicated RAM was a bad point on the PS3 because the PS3 only had 256 MB of it for the RSX and 256 MB for the system, which in a way crippled both.

And I'm not talking about optimization, I'm talking about pure graphical power. (And PCs have mod optimization to help as well, btw)



                                                                                                               You're Gonna Carry That Weight.

Xbox One - PS4 - Wii U - PC