Surprised Bloodborne didn't make the list, that's certainly my top announcement although the excitement was tempered by the leaks.

Zelda Wii U at #1 as it should be. It was the best thing shown.

I disagree. The game is supposed to be out at the end of next year. Nobody was expecting to have a change to get a hand on MP beta this year.

I would challenge GTA and Uncharted instead. GTA because, well, it is just a already out there (was still a surprise) and for Uncharted, it is just so expected to get this on the PS4 anyway (it was just a matter of announcing it) but it is a 2015 game and they just announced the game will come, nothing like the Halo 5 beta which is coming this year.

I would actually put the PS4 Destiny Alpha or Bloodstone in that list instead of Uncharted. These 2 were, imo, pretty cool for PS4 users.

It was a big suprise. I agree with Rainbow Six too, this game was unexpected :) (as an old Xbox gamer, this game means a lot!).

This was a very "safe" list. It consisted of games from big franchises that the typical consumer watching e3 already knew were in production.

Nintendo's Splatoon and Sony's No Man Sky are unexpected surprises that might turn out to be good games.

Rise of the Tomb Raider was mine followed by Type-0. Square-Enix is love, Square-Enix is life.

It is easily one of the most impressive announcements, ign and gamespot are crap.

A cgi trailewr was the best thing shown? No.

as much as I love Uncharted and feel indifferent about zelda, neither one should have been in the list. We all knew they were coming.

it wasnt a cgi trailer :P

because it would have looked a lot nicer

It wasn't Cgi and has been confirmed.