As much as I love Uncharted, I don't see Uncharted 4 selling more or on par with Halo 5.

Even though I believe U4 can sell more, I'm not gonna argue you there. I am gonna say that both games will surely outsell Zelda U.

UC4 best sales and #

Cant beat more then double the user base by then.

I agree. I don't think Zelda can match Uncharted and Halo numbers.

Talking about Uncharted and Halo, the only thing that could give Uncharted a small edge over Halo is the install base, even though in the past (look Halo 3 vs Halo 4) this wasn't relevant. 

Considering how UC4 sold more than nearly anyone predicted, it's safe to say it flopped hard.

Was there another thread like this? I could swear I posted in one of them.

Zelda still is going to outslell both of them dueto being crossgen now

I'll keep digging. I can't remember my prediction.

Wow looking through this thread was quite interesting...especially to see some of the predictions that were made! It is like Halo 5 and Uncharted 4 swapped places in these predictions!

I don't know. If UC4 manages to sell over 8m, Zelda U will have a tough act to follow. TP managed to sell 8.88m  copies (Wii+GC), and that with the Wii being a massive hit. I don't know if Zelda U can pull off TP numbers, specially with the WiiU's low installbase and the NX being an enigma.