I don't think we did. It was pretty damn amazing!

8

9/10 good conference

8/10 great showing of very interesting games but some sections ran on too long (like Yoshi Wolley World and Splatoon)

Nintendo saved this E3. 9/10 ( not 10 because Nintendo not show Fire emblem x Persona trailer)

7. It was short, but everything was exclusive so I can't blame them. I'd say it's a three way tie. All being good but not amazing.

Impressive! Not a game one would think that it's a Wii U exclusive.

7.9/10
Pure Exclusives and Game Related Content
But the show was too short, and the Developer Commentaries were too long.
Every trailer had gameplay, barely any CGI
the side stuff like Robot Chicken, and Miyamoto fighting we're interesting
Only saw 1 new IP (Splatoon, which looks hella interesting and is FTP I believe) and no indies whatsoever(I actually like Indies, and not dedicating at least a minute to one of them is kinda offputting)
To many commericials, which is ironic because I never see them on the interwebs or TV.
No one game, with the exception of Smash and Zelda, where must buys for me but they build a library that is so much better than what the WIi U had prior, unfortunately most in 2015
X had terrible graphics, just had to point that out.
I was expecting something out of the whole Robot Chicken thing.
Nintendo didn't hold back like MS and took a much larger risk then Sony did.
Appeal was a bit focused but that can't be helped honestly.
Not far from perfect but the issues were glaring enough for me to drop it .01 point out of the 80s
Could be a 9 if less commercials, less talking, more games, and megatons like starfox or metroid or at least more unexpected stuff.

EDIT: Toad was a Negative, Yoshi was a positive.

It was pretty great. 9/10

Seems theyre still announcing games. Devils third and mario party 10. Obviously they didnt want to show such visceral games on their official direct.