Sony - 5 (Mr. President Speech)
MS - 4 (too much CGI)
Ubisoft - 4 (too generic)
Nintendo - 4 (Fan service)
EA -3 (Hey we got games under development)

Ea 0 ubi 1 ms 2 nintendo 2 sony 4.5

Nintendo: 4.5
Sony: 4
Microsoft: 2.5
Ubisoft: 3.5
EA: 2

Nintendo 4

- Excellent presentation style, with humor, dynamism... That was way funnier and more interesting than a press conference !
- Very good new IPs, Captain Toad and Splatoon seems excellent with a new, innovative and very interesting gameplay. Yoshi bluffed me !
- A lot of gameplay shown, unlike Sony and Microsoft, which is very pleasant
- Amiibo is an interesting concept (I probably won't ever buy it though), but I wish that won't give ANY important bonus for competitive games such as MK8 and SSB (please Nintendo be careful about that...)
- I found the output insufficient for 2014 (we only have Bayonetta 2, Captain Toad, Hyrule Warriors, Smash Bros and Pokémon OR/AS). A lot of games for 2015, but definitely not enough for 2014. And I don't understand why, for example the demos of Splatoon or Xenoblade Chronicles X shown on Treehouse almost look like games ready to be marketed
- Nothing about SMT x Fire Emblem, Animal Crossing Wii U, Pokken Fighters... I wish Nintendo has something more about them in the next two Treehouse streams...

Microsoft: 3 - OK show, nothing very remarkable except for the fact that they had games, games and games. Fun to watch but not convincing me to buy an Xbox One yet.

EA: 1 - Battlefront looked amazing, and I admire their work into getting all those small details. Game looked just like the film sets. Unfortunately that was the only good thing and the rest of the games looked the same that I saw in 2008.

Ubisoft: 3 - Aisha Tyler actually got me laughing this year. Another Ubiart Framework game, another Rainbow Six, I felt there was variety. But most of it I've seen before.

Sony: 3 - Same as MS but with weird filler in the middle. Glad we got to see the new CEO of America (or spokesperson, or am I way off here?)

Nintendo: 4 (can't really settle for 3 or 4 but it's closer to 4) - Another year without a full press conference, but this Digital Event was cohesive and straight to the point. I think Zelda deserved a grander reveal but still, from the first frame of it, I was sold. Watched it with a couple of friends and we all made a weird "whoa" sound, so it was good. Not many surprises, most of them were after the main show and I guess we can't take those under consideration.

Sony - 5

Nintendo - 3

 MS - 3

Ubisoft - 3

EA -3

Nintendo 4

Could still get a 5 if the 3DS game they announce is huge. I'm hoping there's another surprise as well.

Nintendo 4/5 - was surprised how entertaining it was. If they had ore 3rd party games in there it would have been a 5

Sony 4/5 - lost a point for predictable games and some boring bits. The white PS4 was nice surprise.

Microsoft 3.5 - some predictable games and nothing too mind blowing that was new.


Didnt watch the others.

Sony : 5 / Nintendo : 3.5 / MS : 2

Nintendo: 5

It's the first time an E3 of theirs has properly impressed me since 2010.