Lol completely dodging what I said or just completely failing to grasp it. I never even mentioned that part of your post about a quick cash-in. Mostly because I agree with your conclusion with what it is though I don't find anything wrong with it. Just like I didn't find anything wrong with a Wind Waker remake or the Halo remake. It's okay though. I wasn't spending any of my time trying to convince you of anything. Just pointing out your hypocritical reasoning to everyone else. They've already seen this conversation and made up their minds. So I've done what I came in this thread to do and I'm done with the conversation. Have a good day. :]

Sales will decide whether this is overkill or not.

God of War Collection released ~ 2-and-a-half years after God of War 2, but people didn't seem to mind then.  In fact, 2.5m people didn't mind very much at all.

Given how many supposed "conversion" stories I read on various places around the internet, too, I don't think this is a particularly bad idea at all.  Will sell to people who traded in their PS3's but would like to keep the game (or want to play online).  Will sell to ex-360/Wii owners or any PC-only gamers who decided they wanted a PS4.  Will sell to anyone who was interested but held off in case of a definitive version (i.e. me.)

Looks fine to me.

but Tlou has an acclaimed multiplayer. So it has 100s of hours of replay value. TR also has fine multiplayer, but has 100s of collectibles so I disagree that linear story lines make the game have little replay value.

The "Remastered Argument" is bogus because it would if it was a simple discounted port of the same game on PS3, their would be a huge fiasco about how the PS4 is barely powerful then the PS3. Every single game of TLOUs caliber has a GOTY edition. This is just that GOTY ported to PS4.

Furthermore, their is no way in hell TLOU remastered would work in 5 years, because the multiplayer would be dead, and the game has already been played. Other Remasters, either have multiple games on disc as a collection, or cross multiple generations and are upscalled.

In other words, its a port not a remaster.

I say yes, especially when it is full priced.

Why does anyone care? If you don't want to buy it again, then don't buy it.

This is a game that has never been on Playstation 4, and I'm glad it's going to be on PS4.

Like Tomb Raider, it is a smoke and mirrors tactic to pay the bills for what is otherwise a summer of lacking content.

Square Enix is one thing, but I am surprised Sony is resorting to price gouging so early in their win.

Not when millions of people won't stop begging for it, lol

It is a strategy for selling PS4 to xbox360 owners, and a good one.

I won't buy it again though.

Only if nobody buys it.

People are going to buy this game. So in this case specifically, no.

Absolutely is overkill lol. Like TR I bought beat and would never rebuy the game when it didn't even have a chance to become a classic. I don't/didnt care about the graphics because they were fine beforehand.