By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Need Pokemon advice! Last Pokemon I played was Pokemon gold.

RealGamingExpert said:
ImmortalHelixFossil said:
RealGamingExpert said:

You should go for Pokemon Black and white 2 and then X / Y.
Black and white 2 have a huge amount of pokemon and its more focused on the story.
I dont think there are any side quests in any pokemon game... But the post game of some games has to offer some additional stuff like the battle frontier in pokemon emerald. I think there is also one in platinum.
I would go for Black -> Black 2 -> X / Y
I dont really like black / white 1 because you can only catch the new pokemon, but the story in B / W 2 would be easier to understand if you played b / w 1.

You could also go for platinum, i think it has the biggest post game content and imo the most interesting story of any pokemon game. You should be able to get it really cheap by now.


Yeah seems like I will get Pokemon Black/White. Is there any big difference? And if I get Pokemon Black/White 2 first will I get blown away with what's going on?


I dont think there is a big difference, only a few other pokemon.

Depends if you play it for the story! It would help to know the main characters from black / white.


As Smeags pointed out, BW has gen V only pokemon (making it unique in that respective).BW2 is the better game, especially post game has alot of content



Around the Network
tbone51 said:
RealGamingExpert said:
ImmortalHelixFossil said:
RealGamingExpert said:

You should go for Pokemon Black and white 2 and then X / Y.
Black and white 2 have a huge amount of pokemon and its more focused on the story.
I dont think there are any side quests in any pokemon game... But the post game of some games has to offer some additional stuff like the battle frontier in pokemon emerald. I think there is also one in platinum.
I would go for Black -> Black 2 -> X / Y
I dont really like black / white 1 because you can only catch the new pokemon, but the story in B / W 2 would be easier to understand if you played b / w 1.

You could also go for platinum, i think it has the biggest post game content and imo the most interesting story of any pokemon game. You should be able to get it really cheap by now.


Yeah seems like I will get Pokemon Black/White. Is there any big difference? And if I get Pokemon Black/White 2 first will I get blown away with what's going on?


I dont think there is a big difference, only a few other pokemon.

Depends if you play it for the story! It would help to know the main characters from black / white.


As Smeags pointed out, BW has gen V only pokemon (making it unique in that respective).BW2 is the better game, especially post game has alot of content

I thought he meant a difference between black 1 and white 1. My mistake, sorry.



If you're interested in Nintendo content and understand german, maybe you want to take a look at my youtube channel! :)

https://www.youtube.com/user/RealGamingExpert

I'd say Black2/White2, or Emerald...


Black2/White2 have awesome story and plot, and it's filled with tons and tons of battles. The music is amazing, it's challenging but not too hard, and I love the Pokemon. Has a lot of content after beating the main story, but it's not so good... I didn't find it interesting.


If you somehow get a GBA, I'd highly recommend Emerald. It's very, very time consuming (but you might not like that), and is the one I found myself more inmersed with, because the map is big and all filled with water, so it has tons of secrets! And as a kid, I played it over 100+ just to know what's hidden in every single corner...



Bet with bluedawgs: I say Switch will outsell PS4 in 2018, he says PS4 will outsell Switch. He's now permabanned, but the bet will remain in my sig.

NNID: Slarvax - Steam: Slarvax - Friend Code:  SW 7885-0552-5988

RealGamingExpert said:

I thought he meant a difference between black 1 and white 1. My mistake, sorry.

its all good :)



I'd love to say just go for X and Y because they're the newest but they a.) don't have a "good" story and b.) they don't have shit for after you beat the Champion.

If you want to play more for the story I'd say get Black/White. While the story isn't the best by most stardards for Pokemon, it's as good as it gets. I myself actually consider B/W to be the best so far because of the focus on the story which was like I said "great" by Pokemon's standards. Another thing a liked was that you can ONLY use gen 5 Pokemon untill the post game. Also if you end up liking B/W you can always buy B2/W2 which is overflowing with content as well as havng a pokedex of 300 pokemon.

If you're more into exploration I'd say go with Platinum. The Sinnoh region is the 2nd most varied region in all of Pokemon (Hoenn is just edges it out but since you can't play Emerald on 3DS it doesn't really matter) and is a blast to explore. The story is pretty good as well and theres a good variety of Pokemon to catch. Also Platinum has quiet a bit of post game content with lots of legendaries to catch and a new Island to explore. The onlt down side to Platinum (and gen 4 in general) is that the games can feel sluggish compare to others in the series.

In X/Y'sm favor they do have a longer "main campaign" and ~450 pokemon in it's Pokedex. The Kalos region is pretty cool as well but I'd wait to see what the third version (or squeal) brings to the table before jumping into 6th gen.



PSN: extremeM

PlayStation Vita Japanese Software Sales (Media Create Physical/ Famitsu Digital)

Around the Network

If you want a Pokemon game to back into Pokemon, I definitely wouldn't play Black/White/Black2/White2. There's no real post game content, so once you beat the game, that's basically it. BW have the most new Pokemon, but they also have no old Pokemon, so it's not really the best revisit as a result.

As far as I remember, no Pokemon game but Pokemon XY have side quests, and the Looker quest is post game content. However, most of them have side content that can be very enjoyable or kind of stupid. BW has one of the worst with Pokemon Musicals, but B2W2 has one of the best, with Pokestar Studios. However, like someone else said, you can't really play 2 without playing 1.

As for Pokemon Platinum, I'll explain further why you should play it by expanding on all of your points:

- A lot of different Pokemons that can hook me for weeks.

Pokemon Platinum has a Pokedex size of 210 before you beat the game and the number basically doubles. It has a fantastic mix of new and old Pokemon and does an even better job of taking old Pokemon and evolving them into new ones, so even with some of the newer guys, you'll be vaguely familiar with them.

- Great story, one that makes me read what's happening instead of raping the A button.

Again, the story is not on The Last of Us levels, but for what it is, it's great. You're stopping a man who wants to tamper with the fabrics of time and space through this games legendary Pokemon, Dialga and Palkia, but things don't quite go as planned. The gym leaders all have personality and the companion, Barry, while really hyperactive impatient, is ultimately kind and likable and goes through touching and noticeable character development, something most Pokemon games lack.

There are spoilers out there, so I'd advise you NOT to look at any reviews. Perhaps look at numerical scores, but there is one spoiler about this game that EVERY review brings up, so DON'T spoil it for yourself, because discovering it for yourself will give you the best experience.

- A lot of side quests or missions (if that's possible)

While there aren't any real side quests, Pokemon Platinum has a LOT of side content. There are Pokemon Contests, an addictive mini game that has you use battle commands, rhythm, and decorations to participate in a sort of "beauty contest" with your Pokemon. Your pokemon have Contest stats that are increased by making these pastries called Poffins, which are a minigame all on their own. There is the Sinnoh underground, which is this entire underground tunnel system where you can mine for important items like Pokemon fossils, play mini games, and create a secret base that you can decorate into your own little bachelor pad. There is the Wifi Plaza with even more mini games. You can costomize the Pokeball animation your Pokemon have with Pokeball seals.

- Something to do after I beated the Pokemon league, and that's interesting

After you beat the Pokemon league, the entire Battle Frontier opens up where you can battle in these five facilities that have you battle with specific quirky rules and limitations and then battle the leaders to gain their "tokens." It's really fun, and WAY more challenging than the gym leaders. The battle frontier is part of this entire mini region where you can catch exotic Pokemon, battle tougher trainers, and you even get a surprise gift from a stranger that's pretty bad ass and gives you a reason to spend obscene amounts of money.

- Gigantic map compared with Pokemon G/S/C

The Pre and post game map is so huge that they had to split the Sinnoh region into East and West Sinnoh. And the Battle Frontier Island.



spemanig said:

If you want a Pokemon game to back into Pokemon, I definitely wouldn't play Black/White/Black2/White2. There's no real post game content, so once you beat the game, that's basically it. BW have the most new Pokemon, but they also have no old Pokemon, so it's not really the best revisit as a result.

As far as I remember, no Pokemon game but Pokemon XY have side quests, and the Looker quest is post game content. However, most of them have side content that can be very enjoyable or kind of stupid. BW has one of the worst with Pokemon Musicals, but B2W2 has one of the best, with Pokestar Studios. However, like someone else said, you can't really play 2 without playing 1.

As for Pokemon Platinum, I'll explain further why you should play it by expanding on all of your points:

- A lot of different Pokemons that can hook me for weeks.

Pokemon Platinum has a Pokedex size of 210 before you beat the game and the number basically doubles. It has a fantastic mix of new and old Pokemon and does an even better job of taking old Pokemon and evolving them into new ones, so even with some of the newer guys, you'll be vaguely familiar with them.

- Great story, one that makes me read what's happening instead of raping the A button.

Again, the story is not on The Last of Us levels, but for what it is, it's great. You're stopping a man who wants to tamper with the fabrics of time and space through this games legendary Pokemon, Dialga and Palkia, but things don't quite go as planned. The gym leaders all have personality and the companion, Barry, while really hyperactive impatient, is ultimately kind and likable and goes through touching and noticeable character development, something most Pokemon games lack.

There are spoilers out there, so I'd advise you NOT to look at any reviews. Perhaps look at numerical scores, but there is one spoiler about this game that EVERY review brings up, so DON'T spoil it for yourself, because discovering it for yourself will give you the best experience.

- A lot of side quests or missions (if that's possible)

While there aren't any real side quests, Pokemon Platinum has a LOT of side content. There are Pokemon Contests, an addictive mini game that has you use battle commands, rhythm, and decorations to participate in a sort of "beauty contest" with your Pokemon. Your pokemon have Contest stats that are increased by making these pastries called Poffins, which are a minigame all on their own. There is the Sinnoh underground, which is this entire underground tunnel system where you can mine for important items like Pokemon fossils, play mini games, and create a secret base that you can decorate into your own little bachelor pad. There is the Wifi Plaza with even more mini games. You can costomize the Pokeball animation your Pokemon have with Pokeball seals.

- Something to do after I beated the Pokemon league, and that's interesting

After you beat the Pokemon league, the entire Battle Frontier opens up where you can battle in these five facilities that have you battle with specific quirky rules and limitations and then battle the leaders to gain their "tokens." It's really fun, and WAY more challenging than the gym leaders. The battle frontier is part of this entire mini region where you can catch exotic Pokemon, battle tougher trainers, and you even get a surprise gift from a stranger that's pretty bad ass and gives you a reason to spend obscene amounts of money.

- Gigantic map compared with Pokemon G/S/C

The Pre and post game map is so huge that they had to split the Sinnoh region into East and West Sinnoh. And the Battle Frontier Island.


Thank you so much! You convienced me that I should buy Pokemon Platinum first and continue with Black/white 1/2. You are right, I won't look for any reviews, because I want to keep everything a surprise and don't want to have any clue what I can expect. Hopefully I will like it a lot. For everyone else, thanks for taking your time to tell me what I can expect with every version =)



Once you entered you won't be the same anymore. A blog about life.

http://seetheworlddifferent.wordpress.com/

To be 100% honest, I consider Gold to be the last good one everyone I've played since Including the latest Pokemon Y has been a let down to me.

Pokemon Y started off fun but that effect quickly wore off on me :(



Go for Heart Gold / Soul Silver. Not just my favourite Pokemon game, but one of my favourite games of all time.

Also go for Pokemon X / Y. I'm enjoying it, it's the hot thing at the moment and also has online features, so you'll be able to trade / battle / discuss with more players.

Have to agree with think-man though, X / Y was a bit of a let down for me after the first few hours. The game does have some deep rooted flaws. :-/



Considering you seemed to have gone with Platinum, I will advise that you go with B2/W2 afterward. B2/W2 is one of the best Pokemon games I have played and it really expands upon the original B/W. In fact, you can just skip B/W all together.

X/Y are quite fun a really do a lot to help the Pokemon series move forward, but it wasn't as fun to me as some of the other entries into the series. The post-game was an absolute bore, also.