Torn between Thief and Castlevania. Probably the latter.

I'm gonna go with Castlevania. I liked the first Lords of Shadows and I will probably like the second one to but from what I have seen not to many people were/are excited that they're favorite 2D side-scrolling action adventure platformer suddenly turned into a hack and slash game. And not that I trust Edge and their reviews but the rated it 4. I also remember reading somewhere that GameInformer rated it 6 so the metascore should be pretty low unless all other sites rate way higher.

Weird selection of games, especially CoD doesn't fit, you should have included inFamous or Ground Zeroes.

From the games at hand? I think Castlevania. Titanfall or DS2 the highest, probably Souls.

Castlevania.

Thief - 76%
Castlevania LoS 2 - 81%
COD 2014 - 83%
Dark Souls 2 - 87%
Titanfall - 95%

Lords of Shadow 2 and rightfully so. Konami needs to treat the Castlevania with respect like they used to back in the day.

There is no freaking way Titanfall will get the worst out of those 5! The press are all playing the beta and loving it.

Probably Castlevania, didn't Edge give it a really low score?

Castlevania.

Titanfall is not going to get a low score. For one, the press isn't going to change now, not after all the hype and praise--that would make them look kind of dumb. Two, it's multi-player only; barring server issues, multi-player games usually require long periods of time before all the problems get discovered. Balance issues, exploits, and bad mechanics are things are often not apparent until millions of play hours have been logged. Since most reviewers judge based on beta game-play, criteria like that get overlooked.

and your answer to the question is??

forgot that cod ghosts got bad score??