The PS4 is also locked at 60fps, it just drops more frequently under than the X1 version. So it's not 100% smooth on X1 like AC4 on PS4.

In fact the average of 51fps is calculated only with action scenes, otherwise in fact the game sustains 60fps more often than you think because Eurogamer cherry picked the more heavy scenes. I would say 51fps average on heavy action scenes is quite good.

But there is screen tear on X1 almost each time the game drops under 30fps, there is none at all on PS4. Eurogamer conveniently forgotten to talk about it. They did talk about it when there was some screen tear on COD/PS4 or even some exceptionnaly rare case (less than here) of teared screen for PS4/Lego game when it was more often (with framerate drops in X1 Lego version).

Why didn't they talk about the frequent screen tear on X1? (please notice the not so locked 30fps of the X1 version, juddering + low input lag + screen tearing here). In those scenes we can really see an average 20fps gap between the 2 versions which is roughly what was expected: PS4 performs 70% better than X1 when we can fairly judge the framerate gap under action sequences (when both are not locked to either 30fps or 60fps).

The Xbox One version dipped to 18fps, at one point.  And...you're STILL spinning?!  *sighs*

You know, if there's some type of uhh..."cerebral issue"...where maybe me and others can look at your posts in a different light in the future, then...my inbox is open.  I'm so sincere when I say that...

moderated kasz216

Good stabiliaty for Xbone version, even with the 24 fps dip it average is really close the apex, so consistence is good.

Now on PS4, what a power to have peak double Xbox, but maybe they could lock around 45 (if we see average and bigger dip it would be better) or would that be too hard to synch with tv output??? Probably if someone with the interest and experience of a 1st party done the port we could have 60fps "locked"

Xbone version should have been locked to 25 FPS.

This kind of perfectly thinked post isn't allowed...

And I agree with your points, and it's a good thing Xbone is locked, and I would lock PS3 version at 45 if possible.

Pretty much like Sony/MS do from time to time with some titles.

NEXT GEN IS HERE!!!

"Why the hell is the PS4 version dipping so low."
"Bad for both"
"That's pretty crappy for both"
"Its interesting to see the ps4 version quite frequently drop to 40 42"

Let me get this straight. Xone runs at 30fps and ps4 runs at 51fps on average. ps4 is getting hammered that has 20fps advantage?

I dont see why.

I dont claim the Xbox 1 version batter. And it is a shame we wont know the fames on an uncapped Xbox vesion. When the PS4 is fluctuating into the 30's the Xbox version didnt drop from 30. So It would have been nice to see where Xbox 1 would get to when PS4  was up arounf 50-60. Maybe 40 - 50? We unfotuantely wont know. But my guess is The Xbox version fluctuateed more so they capped it. Theres no reason why if PS4 in scenes was between 34 - 50 and Xbox same scene was solid 30 all the way through that Xbox 1 could of reached 40 - 50 when PS4 was 60. But the juddering was probably alot more noticeable on Xbox due to bigger fluctutations betwen 30 - 50.

All in all the Xbox isnt miles behind PS4 in terms of power. Theres a 20 fps difference on average with 1 capped and 1 not. So who knows uncapped the difference may have been between 10 -15 fps on average. Either way capped Xbox 1 version was probably the way to go for Xbox.

Only by reasonable users... well they say they are.