Currently Nintendo has all top 4 next gen rated exclusives and people are making the excuse the Wii U's been out for a year and X1/PS4 just came out, even though Microsoft released their highest rated exclusive last gen and it didn't come close, and Sony released one of their highest rated exclusives and its the same story.  

In 1 year's time I predict Nintendo will still have at least all top 4 rated exclusives on their console.  With games like SSB and Mario Kart that I think we can all agree are garanteed to get crazy high scores and other games like DK and X that have a chance of pulling those high numbers.  Not to mention Zelda U could come out since Nintendo likes to reveal big games at E3 and release them that same year.  

Titanfall will get instant 10/10 from every major reviewer guaranteed. I don't see Mario Kart 8 doing that great, console Mario Karts usually score in the 80-90 range. Which is good but it won't be one of the 4 highest rated games.

My guess:
1. Super Smash Bros
2. Titanfall
3. Super Mario 3D World
4. Infamous Second Son

Not an exclusive.  Also the same thing can be said the Infamous games which have are in the 80-90 range.

I can see Nintendo having three out of the top four. Titanfall should do well with reviewers. 

Edit: Obvious hiccup is obvious. 

Are you saying Nintendo has ties with reviewers? Under-the-table like ties?

Conspiracies don't make friends.

Well duh all they do is release Mario Zelda pokemon

Well it's a next gen exclusive, unless of course you count PC. As for Infamous, maybe it's just wishful thinking on my part but I think Second Son looks likea class above it's predecessors. I expect some great reviews.

4 out of 4? you're crazy. they may take the top spot 4 of 4 is crazy talk.

Next Halo and Infamous have a good chance. Also Titanfall (if you count it)

You think that Infamous Second Son will have a 90+ meta score ? (Wind Waker HD sits at 90)