MikeB said: 360 IMO impossible - Too many hardware issues (even if RRoD problems are reduced towards industry standards DVD problems will get worse in course of time due to wearing from having to spin so much at high speeds => bad reputation) - the bulk of XBox users already upgraded - hardware has been pushed near its peak potential - Microsoft isn't really a popular brand anywhere outside of the US (a little more in Australia and UK than in other places) Provide people a good alternative and I think they the bulk of consumers will take the alternative instead. - 360 is a non factor for Japan - Microsoft seemingly putting no efforts into European localizations - Lack of real high profile exclusives (most timed exclusives hit the PC as well), even a Halo 4 or Gears 2 wouldn't accomplish much as most Halo fans already upgraded, Gears 2 can be expected for at least the PC (probably better) and Resistance 2 and Killzone 2 will probably steal any thunder due to technical reasons.
PS3 IMO likely - PSX and PS2 both sold beyond 100 million units. - PS3 is being cost reduced fast. Sony has an excellent track record wtih regard to slimming down and cost reducing their consoles. - A lot of headroom for developers to make much more impressive games for years to come. - The amount of high profile exclusives is overwhelming, almost all high profile PS2 exclusives are known to see sequels on the PS3. In addition several successful new franchises have been introduced. - Blu-Ray is winning the high definition format war and the PS3 has the reputation of being the best upgradeable Blu-Ray movie player next to being far more multi-functional. (even DVR functionality and extensive PSP connectivity) - Home service looks very promising and pretty unique. - HDTV and 7.1 audio setup install base is growing rapidly. 1080p set have become increasingly popular. |
I think you're exaggerating the roadblocks the 360 faces by quite a bit, but we agree that the end result is "no chance at all the 360 will get to 100m" so we'll leave that alone unless you insist.
On the PS3 side, however, I do have a few objections:
1. The PSX and PS2 were both market leaders -- i.e. in "first place". The "second place" console got about 33 and 25 million respectively.
2. It's true that the PS3 is getting a lot of cost reductions and price reductions, and that there are surely more to come. However, you have to remember that the PS3 started with its price and cost SO HIGH that it has that much further to go before it gets to "mass market" pricing. It's STILL as expensive as the Premium was at launch, despite all the price cuts!
3. Just like any console. Why would this help the PS3 so much more?
4. All the consoles are getting great exclusives. PS3 may have more than 360 (I would like to see your numbers) but it's not some massive avalanche of awesome that will bury the other console.
5. Blu-ray is an asset but not as much so as you are making out. By the time Blu-ray really takes off in the mass market there will be standalone players much cheaper than PS3 with equal (Blu-ray) functionality.
6. Again, yes this is true but it will not help as much as it would have to to meet the goal you are setting.
7. By the time this stuff truly gets popular enough to make a huge difference the gen will be almost over. It may help the PS3 last a while into the next gen but won't magically give it a giant boost. Most people today don't
really care about 5.1, why will they suddenly care about 7.1?
Strangely, you actually DON'T mention what I think will be one of the PS3's strongest arguments for why sales will take off -- it's kind of a corollary to (2). The fact that even after the price drops it's still not close to mass market pricing means that when it finally DOES get down there sales just might skyrocket! Especially if that event happens to coincide with a giant exclusive nudge nudge wink wink say no more.
For all of the above reasons I think the PS3 will be fighting to break 50 million by end of gen. Some would say that I am deluding myself to say even that number, so just give up the dream of 100 million, OK MikeB?