I prob didnt explain what i meant.  I was referring to metacritic.  We are on two different pages at the moment, momenti :)

I dont know about best multiplayer of the year, but with the crappy story in ghosts and bf4 it doesnt have much competition.

Eventhough personnally I think that KZ is one of the best 1st person shooter franchise out there, I think the total Gaming audience would go for HALO/COD/BF because KZ is somewhat slower (more realistic in my opinion despite of the future/outerspace setting), so COD people will never really get into KZ controlls etc.

Hmm, it will need a pretty fantastic campaign to offset the amazing multiplayer of BF4 and become best overall. I'm not so sure it can, Killzone gameplay is pretty good but the campaigns are nothing special in my opinion.

But do they measure mp and sp separately? No problem for confusion but wasn't intended on out sides, I guess

Well im primarily talking about games with multiplayer.  Bioshock doesnt have multiplayer so it wouldnt be included in what im talking about.

Far Cry 3 would though.  I think i need to replay that game now that im thinking about it XD

You should change the thread title to "Will Killzone Shadowfall be the best all around (MP and Story) shooter that's exclusive to the PS4 and begins with a K". I would definitely say yes. Yes it is.

If we take shooter to mean KZ vs Battlefield vs CoD...

I think it's difficult to say which will be the best, but it seems to have an open goal in terms of story. As for multiplayer, I think much of it comes down to preference. There will be many who want the open vehicle based 64 player combat of the PC version and some who want the more tight confines of CoD, but KZ looks to have an interesting multiplayer and I still love the Warzone game mode, I played a decent of that in Killzone 2

Out of those three I listed, it is the only one I have ordered though I will probably get BF4 as a tech demo on PC

It could be, but then it needs an overhaul on previous iterations' gameplay.

If it is anything like KZ2 AND more improved. Then it will easily take the crown for me. It already looks AMAZING. I personally prefer the gameplay mechanics in KZ over BF or CoD. I like the heavy feel way more and the shooting more. And if the MP is like KZ2 then I am sold! The KZ2 multiplayer was easily better than anything of the COD games(bar COD4) and every BF game. I played that multiplayer ALL the freaking time.