By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Final Fantasy X Collection vs Fable Anniversary vs Wind Waker HD

Final Fantasy 10 will easily outsell them its coming on both Vita and Ps3 after all.



Around the Network
KingdomHeartsFan said:
ktay95 said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:

FF X/X-2 HD over KH 1.5 HD Remix?  OMFG how dare you!

But seriously I'd go with 1. WW HD, 2. FF X/X-2 HD, 3. Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD, 4.Fable HD

FIXED  =)


I don't think so, this is the Final Mix version of KH, this is the version that KH fans outside of Japan have been waiting years to get their hand on.  I have no doubt it will sell better than FF X/X-2 HD.  Well maybe a little doubt.  

all i know is that im getting the first 3 games on that list

and yeah KH1.5 is amazing. especially for me. never finished 1, never played CoM. Then i must wait for 2.5 for BBS and i will have completed the series... UNTIL III



ktay95 said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:
ktay95 said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:

FF X/X-2 HD over KH 1.5 HD Remix?  OMFG how dare you!

But seriously I'd go with 1. WW HD, 2. FF X/X-2 HD, 3. Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD, 4.Fable HD

FIXED  =)


I don't think so, this is the Final Mix version of KH, this is the version that KH fans outside of Japan have been waiting years to get their hand on.  I have no doubt it will sell better than FF X/X-2 HD.  Well maybe a little doubt.  

all i know is that im getting the first 3 games on that list

and yeah KH1.5 is amazing. especially for me. never finished 1, never played CoM. Then i must wait for 2.5 for BBS and i will have completed the series... UNTIL III

What about Dream Drop Distance?



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

JayWood2010 said:

Windwaker > Fable > Final Fantasy

Both Wind Waker and Fable will have more advertising etc Plus they are both overhauled games that look completely different than the original versions. FF is just an HD remastered game.

In this case it'll be the games that has the most effort put in them which is Wind Waker and Fable Anniversary

As far as Im aware there is only one HD Remastered series that has reached 1m and that was the first HD remastered game which is God of War. 

Remakes on the other hand that has effort put in them like Halo Anniversary and Ocarina of Time where you can see big differences both has sold multimillions.

Its also got an extra 30 mins of voice acting and the West will be getting the unreleased international editions, which features plenty of new content never played outside of Japan. Plus ff10 is coming to Ps3 & Vita I cant see it sell less than Fable esp with the popularity of FF in Japan.



think-man said:
JayWood2010 said:

Windwaker > Fable > Final Fantasy

Both Wind Waker and Fable will have more advertising etc Plus they are both overhauled games that look completely different than the original versions. FF is just an HD remastered game.

In this case it'll be the games that has the most effort put in them which is Wind Waker and Fable Anniversary

As far as Im aware there is only one HD Remastered series that has reached 1m and that was the first HD remastered game which is God of War. 

Remakes on the other hand that has effort put in them like Halo Anniversary and Ocarina of Time where you can see big differences both has sold multimillions.

Its also got an extra 30 mins of voice acting and the West will be getting the unreleased international editions, which features plenty of new content never played outside of Japan. Plus ff10 is coming to Ps3 & Vita I cant see it sell less than Fable esp with the popularity of FF in Japan.

I edited it to make sure people know Im talking home consoles.  I stand by what I said.  Most people will not know about extra footage etc.  FF will do good in Japan as it usually does.  Or at least for the first week.  The rest of the world on the other hand is a different story.

I could be wrong but I'd be shocked if FFX Collection sells more than 1m

Wind Waker on the other hand I could see reaching 3m lifetime(Just like Ocarina of Time has managed).  And Fable Anniversary i honestly dont know.  Maybe 700k to 1.5m

Also consider that Wind Waker is on a new console that will have a high attach ratio while Fable and FFX are on consoles that are about to be replaced without backward compatability.




       

Around the Network
JayWood2010 said:
think-man said:
JayWood2010 said:

Windwaker > Fable > Final Fantasy

Both Wind Waker and Fable will have more advertising etc Plus they are both overhauled games that look completely different than the original versions. FF is just an HD remastered game.

In this case it'll be the games that has the most effort put in them which is Wind Waker and Fable Anniversary

As far as Im aware there is only one HD Remastered series that has reached 1m and that was the first HD remastered game which is God of War. 

Remakes on the other hand that has effort put in them like Halo Anniversary and Ocarina of Time where you can see big differences both has sold multimillions.

Its also got an extra 30 mins of voice acting and the West will be getting the unreleased international editions, which features plenty of new content never played outside of Japan. Plus ff10 is coming to Ps3 & Vita I cant see it sell less than Fable esp with the popularity of FF in Japan.

I edited it to make sure people know Im talking home consoles.  I stand by what I said.  Most people will not know about extra footage etc.  FF will do good in Japan as it usually does.  Or at least for the first week.  The rest of the world on the other hand is a different story.

I could be wrong but I'd be shocked if FFX Collection sells more than 1m

Wind Waker on the other hand I could see reaching 3m lifetime(Just like Ocarina of Time has managed).  And Fable Anniversary i honestly dont know.  Maybe 700k to 1.5m

Also consider that Wind Waker is on a new console that will have a high attach ratio while Fable and FFX are on consoles that are about to be replaced without backward compatability.

Fair enough, I think it will sell around 1.2 - 1.5 million. Shadow of the Colossus HD managed 970k and I think FF10 would be alot more popular than that so I think 1m is a little low.



zorg1000 said:
ktay95 said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:
ktay95 said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:

FF X/X-2 HD over KH 1.5 HD Remix?  OMFG how dare you!

But seriously I'd go with 1. WW HD, 2. FF X/X-2 HD, 3. Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD, 4.Fable HD

FIXED  =)


I don't think so, this is the Final Mix version of KH, this is the version that KH fans outside of Japan have been waiting years to get their hand on.  I have no doubt it will sell better than FF X/X-2 HD.  Well maybe a little doubt.  

all i know is that im getting the first 3 games on that list

and yeah KH1.5 is amazing. especially for me. never finished 1, never played CoM. Then i must wait for 2.5 for BBS and i will have completed the series... UNTIL III

What about Dream Drop Distance?

bought it launch day and completed it. i played the 2 DS games the month before to prepare for it



think-man said:
JayWood2010 said:

I edited it to make sure people know Im talking home consoles.  I stand by what I said.  Most people will not know about extra footage etc.  FF will do good in Japan as it usually does.  Or at least for the first week.  The rest of the world on the other hand is a different story.

I could be wrong but I'd be shocked if FFX Collection sells more than 1m

Wind Waker on the other hand I could see reaching 3m lifetime(Just like Ocarina of Time has managed).  And Fable Anniversary i honestly dont know.  Maybe 700k to 1.5m

Also consider that Wind Waker is on a new console that will have a high attach ratio while Fable and FFX are on consoles that are about to be replaced without backward compatability.

Fair enough, I think it will sell around 1.2 - 1.5 million. Shadow of the Colossus HD managed 970k and I think FF10 would be alot more popular than that so I think 1m is a little low.

Im actually getting ready to play through ICO collection again XD  Would be very happy to see it reach 1m.  Collections was selling like brand new games when they first started releasing them but over time not so much

Here is some examples some HD Remastered collections.

All on PS3

God of War Collection - 2.37m
Ico Collection - 0.97
jak & Daxter - 0.58
Devil May Cry - 0.56
Sly Cooper - 0.51
God of War Origins - 0.44
Ratchet & Clank - 0.37



For some reason I couldnt find the MGS Collection but I assume it sold decent.

EDIT: Is Metal Gear Solid HD Collection in the VGC database?  I really can't find it.




       

JayWood2010 said:
think-man said:
JayWood2010 said:

I edited it to make sure people know Im talking home consoles.  I stand by what I said.  Most people will not know about extra footage etc.  FF will do good in Japan as it usually does.  Or at least for the first week.  The rest of the world on the other hand is a different story.

I could be wrong but I'd be shocked if FFX Collection sells more than 1m

Wind Waker on the other hand I could see reaching 3m lifetime(Just like Ocarina of Time has managed).  And Fable Anniversary i honestly dont know.  Maybe 700k to 1.5m

Also consider that Wind Waker is on a new console that will have a high attach ratio while Fable and FFX are on consoles that are about to be replaced without backward compatability.

Fair enough, I think it will sell around 1.2 - 1.5 million. Shadow of the Colossus HD managed 970k and I think FF10 would be alot more popular than that so I think 1m is a little low.

Im actually getting ready to play through ICO collection again XD  Would be very happy to see it reach 1m.  Collections was selling like brand new games when they first started releasing them but over time not so much

Here is some examples some HD Remastered collections.

All on PS3

God of War Collection - 2.37m
Ico Collection - 0.97
jak & Daxter - 0.58
Devil May Cry - 0.56
Sly Cooper - 0.51
God of War Origins - 0.44
Ratchet & Clank - 0.37



For some reason I couldnt find the MGS Collection but I assume it sold decent.

Yeah still people have been dying for a good Final Fantasy and this was considered the last good one, so I can see people snapping it up. And it was very very popular selling more than any other game thats been HD remade. Time will tell I guess :P



I'll be getting Final Fantasy X/X-2, Fable HD, and Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD Remix. Don't have a Wii U so can't get Wind Waker. I think it'll be Wind Final Fantasy>Wind Waker> Kingdom Hearts> Fable.