I love both equally but differently. They're both different games, after all. However, I personally prefer Smash Bros. PSASBR is very offensive because of the supers while Smash I find is more defensive (well based on how I play at least).Plus Smash is not very complex so it is easy to pick up and play. Don't get me wrong that doesn't suggest it is shallow. There is depth in the game and you can use strategy too, but I like that it is so accessible. Also, the ring outs and percentage factor can put you on your seat during a match. There are certain touches PSASBR is missing. I felt they didn't want to emulate Smash too much so they tried to go in a totally different direction, and in the process they left out somethings that I thought were essential. Despite its flaws I have a lot of fun with it. Personally, PSASBR is a good game but it has a long way to go still. Hopefully the next game will have more refinements.