By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Do we really need to kill animals??

Porcupine_I said:
KHlover said:
Dr.Grass said:
Gehirnkrampf said:
You have to think about that:
All the animals we eat were born to be eaten. If noone eats them, they would not be born.

So basically, eating meat doesnt take lives. It gives life.


Might  as well start breeding me some nice Scandanavian ass in my basement eh genius.

I"m really getting fed up with stupidity like this.

You're supposedly German, you're letting your forefathers down with your lack of brains.

Well, technically he is right, at least to some degree: The mass production of meat DOES require a higher-than-natural birth rate to fulfill our needs. But his conclusion...no words.

actually i heard people arguing that way about saving the buffalo

nobody will care to breed buffalo unless they can make a profit. if you want the buffalo to  live, better eat its meat and peole will make sure it will stay alive.

Yeah.... a lot of the ones from yellow stone carry diseases with them and are gunned down a lot if they wonder into private properties, their numbers have increased a lot over the years. Even if we don't eat them, we'll still kill them anyways if we feel threatened, funny how that works. Buffalo meat doesn't taste that good either, kinda dry in general.



Around the Network

I care more about the plants than the animal. Beef eating should be reduced so poor South Americans do not continue to cut down the rainforest to raise cattle for Notre Americanos. My issue is with human population, the earth needs less people. When you fuck wear a rubber and do the earth some good.



BTW, where is yogurt in all of this? I eat like one spoon of really good yogurt a day and it helps with my digestive system by replenishing the required goods, after consuming raw garlic which most likely killed some good bacteria in my intestines. Can't make that without milk now can we?



dahuman said:



 

 

 

 

Yeah.... a lot of the ones from yellow stone carry diseases with them and are gunned down a lot if they wonder into private properties, their numbers have increased a lot over the years. Even if we don't eat them, we'll still kill them anyways if we feel threatened, funny how that works. Buffalo meat doesn't taste that good either, kinda dry in general.

It is dry, but it tasted the same as beef to me. I've also had Ostrich which I like. I want to try boar burger next. (Yay for fuddruckers)



Well actually meat is the only place you can easily get the complete proteins your body needs to run correctly and you to be healthy. Soy "can" supply the proteins but it needs to be fermented for about a year or more before the body can process it. (There was an article written up by a nutritionist about the facts and fiction about soy use I will try to find it later.) And the way that soy is processed currently you get no nutritional value from any of it forms (even most tofu isn't made properly today), all soy does in introduce toxins into your system that does more damage then good. One of them is a neurotoxin that causes early on-set dementia.

Other than that to get the proteins any other way you have to eat certain amounts of certain vegetables in the correct amounts to get the proper nutrition. You cannot just through a salad together with some of the now in vogue items and live healthy, that is why some vegan look so sickly they are not getting the correct amount of proteins so their body can function normally. It just a lot of work that almost all people don't want to go through.

Though yes we do eat way too much meat in today society. We are only suppose to have a few ounces a day and that is enough to supply the body with enough complete protein to allow you to stay healthy. But most people prefer to go out and get fast food which supplies you with too many starches and too much protien especially if you eat there more than once a day.



Around the Network
BlkPaladin said:
Well actually meat is the only place you can easily get the complete proteins your body needs to run correctly and you to be healthy. Soy "can" supply the proteins but it needs to be fermented for about a year or more before the body can process it. (There was an article written up by a nutritionist about the facts and fiction about soy use I will try to find it later.) And the way that soy is processed currently you get no nutritional value from any of it forms (even most tofu isn't made properly today), all soy does in introduce toxins into your system that does more damage then good. One of them is a neurotoxin that causes early on-set dementia.

Other than that to get the proteins any other way you have to eat certain amounts of certain vegetables in the correct amounts to get the proper nutrition. You cannot just through a salad together with some of the now in vogue items and live healthy, that is why some vegan look so sickly they are not getting the correct amount of proteins so their body can function normally. It just a lot of work that almost all people don't want to go through.

Though yes we do eat way too much meat in today society. We are only suppose to have a few ounces a day and that is enough to supply the body with enough complete protein to allow you to stay healthy. But most people prefer to go out and get fast food which supplies you with too many starches and too much protien especially if you eat there more than once a day.

I have said all of this through out this thread. However you said it much better. So kudos to you.



If God didn't want me to eat pigs, why did he make them taste like delicious bacon?!?!



zero129 said:
kain_kusanagi said:
zero129 said:
kain_kusanagi said:
zero129 said:
kain_kusanagi said:
I hunt and fish which means I kill animals myself, cut them up, cook them and eat them. When I grew up my parents would raise a steer or a heifer for a year or two and then slaughter it. I helped take care of it and then I helped slaughter it. The beef I eat comes from a local farm and is humanly slaughtered. I know where my meat comes from and I am well aware of nature of life and death. Animals aren't people so your alien analogy falls completely flat.

With that said, I don't approve of the mistreatment of animals that big corporations cause.

However, nothing will stop me from enjoying meat. An hour long propaganda piece on meat isn't going to "open my eye" or make me rethink anything. We are all part of the same ecco-system and circle of life. We earned the right to be at the top of the food chain. Animals are rightfully our food and we are the stewards of the ecco-system that we climbed to the top of. Animal abuse and neglect disgusts me, but local ranchers here in Oregon don't mistreat their animals.

My advice to you is to buy locally sourced meat products from trusted small businesses. Go to a butcher for meat instead of Safeway. Ask where it came from and if the butcher can't tell you the rancher's name go to another butcher.

Fight animal abuse not meat eaters.

I just hope if aliens ever do decide to visit us they dont think like you in the bolded parts.

As for the rest its good you at least care how the animals are killed xD.

I will say it again. Your alien analogy falls flat.

I'll illustrate it with a question:

A scuba diver is eaten Shark and a man eats a hamburger. Which is the greater tragedy?

The man eating the hamburger. Well the scuba divers life would of been a great loss on the grand scale of things both loses where bad. but the shark is a carnivor and will eat meat no matter what type its in their system, well the human eating the hamburger choose to do so.

Basicly in a world where we are meant to be the only animals that "Knows" right from wrong we sure do alot of wrong and to things we see as less powerful then us.

Didnt we outlaw racism cos of this? The white man, or people with money used to think it was ok to inslave and capture other humans as long as they where not white? or the same as them?. so yeah my alien analogy doesnt fall flat. Cos as long as people think its ok to be so crual and bad to a lesser species we have no reason to think a more advanced species then us wouldnt think the same way.

I mean wouldnt it suck if Karma came around to bite us in the ass and we ended up getting captued and taking over by aliens and breed and used as livestock for them?. like they only see us as lesser animals so its in their right to do what they want with us.

Also no one here i dont think have even watched the video -_- .


If you believe that then you need tot ake a vacation and go spend a weekend at a nice bread and breakfast in a nice small town. Unplug from the internet, meet new people and reevaluate your priorities.

If you think a man eating a burger is a tragedy but not a diver killed by a shark I want you to consider how the diver's family feels for their loss. The cow harvested for the burger was not missed by it's herd.

Stop comparing humans to animals. This falacy is the reason your alien analogy is so flawed and why you can't see it yourself.

As a pet owner and animal lover who believes that animals deserve respect and should be treated with kindness believe that there is no difference between a lion eating a zebra and a man eating a hamburger. However there is a HUGE difference between a shark killing a man and a man killing a deer. Both men are loved and love other humans. The shark and the deer are souless.

To the bolded i ask you how do you know this? how do you know what that animal is feeling or what its family feels?.

To the underlined. You have still not explained why this fails but yet i have showing you how it is true.

Did the white people years ago not think black people where nothing but animals?, did the white people not enslave, Capture, kill and torture lots of them just like we do with animals today with no 2nd thought cos they thought they didnt think like them? cos they couldnt understand what they where saying?, cos they thought they where inferior beings?? did hitler and the nazis not do the same to the jews etc etc? this list could go on and on.

But pretty much us humans or most of us seem to be ok with doing bad things to other humans or species as long as we cant understand how they feel or dont want to understand. So why would aliens if they came here see us any different then we have seen ourselfs and pretty much every other specie on this planet? as nothing more then something to be used??.


You've done it again. You've argued that animals have the same value as humans. If you're going to continue to push such an insulting point of view I afraid I must leave this discussion.

I hope one day you learn to value your fellow humans even the slightest bit more than beasts. The same, by the way, beasts that eat the beasts we eat.

Good day to you.



we obviously don't need meat and i once read that vegetarians die much later as non-vegetarians on average (but the main reason should be that they are also more active and stuff)

i think there is no problem in eating animals, animals also eat animals (at least many of them). but i don't really like how many of those animals have to live. animals shouldn't suffer before their death. if they would have a good life it would be even good to eat animals because otherwise these animals (pigs as example) would have never seen this planet, they are only born because we want to eat them.

so, give the animals a better life, if it will cost more for us then i have no prob with it, i just eat it little bit less then. you can already buy meat from farms where you can see that the animals had an awesome life, it costs maybe more but the animal didn't suffer and did only live because i want to eat it, win win^^



This made me hungry. Im going to go out back and slaughter a pig now.