By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Uncharted 3 vs Gears of War 3 (revisited)

 

Uncharted 3 vs Gears of War 3 (total lifetime sales)

Uncharted 3 647 72.86%
 
Gears of War 3 241 27.14%
 
Total:888
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
dsgrue3 said:
ninjablade said:
dsgrue3 said:
ninjablade said:
 as i said before show me  one game that does 2 million its first 10 weeks and goes on to double it sales in a 4 year time period. my research shows that only mass bundled games have been able to sell over 2 million in there first 10 weeks and then double there sales in less then 3 years.

 

ninjablade said:
why don't any of you show me game that' sold over 2 million and not bundled double it sales after 10 weeks,

 

 

You are asking two different things in these posts, would you make up your mind?

@Top - You say 10 weeks sales of 2 million that doubled.

@Bold - You say a game that's sold over 2 million lifetime double its 10 week sales.

Which do you want? Learn to say what you actually mean...

 

just show me the bolded, or show me a game that sold over 2 million and didint take a 50% drop the next year, all of the bundled games did'nt take a 60-70% drop the next year like 99% of the un bundled games.

Grand Theft Auto 4 (PS3):

10 weeks: 4,261,592

LTD: 9,572,737

the reason for that one is because ps3 install base was so small at the time, and i also said 4 years time.


Shut up, seriously. When the first Uncharted game came out, the PS3 install base was even smaller than when GTA4 came out. So cut the crap with the double standard. 

i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real



Around the Network
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your dim-witted agenda with something actually valid for once.



Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your agenda filled claims for once.

i will hold on and uncharted DF did 200,000 first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping, in what world has a game not mass bundled been able to do 200,000 in  first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping season and go on to do 3 million in the us, that game only sold that much cause of bundles, it would have never crossed 1 million in the us.



ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your agenda filled claims for once.

i will hold on and uncharted DF did 200,000 first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping, in what world has a game not mass bundled been able to do 200,000 in  first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping season and go on to do 3 million in the us, that game only sold that much cause of bundles, it would have never crossed 1 million in the us.

The heck are you talking about? Drake's Fortune is at 2.11 in all of North America. 



Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your agenda filled claims for once.

i will hold on and uncharted DF did 200,000 first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping, in what world has a game not mass bundled been able to do 200,000 in  first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping season and go on to do 3 million in the us, that game only sold that much cause of bundles, it would have never crossed 1 million in the us.

The heck are you talking about? Drake's Fortune is at 2.11 in all of North America. 

point still remains if you can find any game in the states that sold 200,000 units its first 10 weeks with  the shopping holiday included and went to sell only 1.5 million units in the states i will happily eat crow and shut up.



Around the Network
ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your agenda filled claims for once.

i will hold on and uncharted DF did 200,000 first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping, in what world has a game not mass bundled been able to do 200,000 in  first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping season and go on to do 3 million in the us, that game only sold that much cause of bundles, it would have never crossed 1 million in the us.

The heck are you talking about? Drake's Fortune is at 2.11 in all of North America. 

point still remains if you can find any game in the states that sold 200,000 units its first 10 weeks with  the shopping holiday included and went to sell only 1.5 million units in the states i will happily eat crow and shut up.

You keep changing the criteria. 
So instead of trying to put the burden of proof on my hands, asking me to do YOUR job, and since you dimiss any games we mention, why don't you go ahead and post a list that illustrates the findings of your research?

I'll mention a game as well, since unlike you I have good faith: Batman Arkham Asylum. Slow start, never bundled.  You'll dimiss it because it wasn't released during the holiday... But whatever. Uncharted was released when the install  base in the US was abysmal. Here, anyone can twist and spin. But that doesn't take us far.



Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
Hynad said:
ninjablade said:
i did'nt know uncharted can be compared to one of the biggest franshises of all time, and uncharted Df did'nt just duble it sales, it almost quadrupled, the fact is not even one game selling over 2 million  units in its 10 weeks, has been able to double it sales, in 2 years after its 10 weeks, only bundled games have been able to achieve such a feat, your gonna tell me uncharted is gonna have longer legs then GTA, get real

Well, you obviously don't know much anyway, but that's beside the point.

Now, since you keep on saying that you did a lot of research about the BS you're trying to pass as facts, I think it's more than due time for you to provide us a list of all those titles ever released on both the PS3 and the 360 that fit these criteria. And I expect you to not omit a single one.

Support your agenda filled claims for once.

i will hold on and uncharted DF did 200,000 first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping, in what world has a game not mass bundled been able to do 200,000 in  first 10 weeks of the busy holiday shopping season and go on to do 3 million in the us, that game only sold that much cause of bundles, it would have never crossed 1 million in the us.

The heck are you talking about? Drake's Fortune is at 2.11 in all of North America. 

point still remains if you can find any game in the states that sold 200,000 units its first 10 weeks with  the shopping holiday included and went to sell only 1.5 million units in the states i will happily eat crow and shut up.

You keep changing the criteria. 
So instead of trying to put the burden of proof on my hands, asking me to do YOUR job, and since you dimiss any games we mention, why don't you go ahead and post a list that illustrates the findings of your research?

I'll mention a game as well, since unlike you I have good faith: Batman Arkham Asylum. Slow start, never bundled.  You'll dimiss it because it wasn't released during the holiday... But whatever. Uncharted was released when the install  base in the US was abysmal. Here, anyone can twist and spin. But that doesn't take us far.

i'm not spinning or twisting anything if a game sells 200,000 during the best time of the year in 10 weeks you know damn well, it only sold cause the bundles, you mention batman, batman did 751,000 with the holidays that year,got a huge boost, i mean you can spin it all you want, but no game in history can achieve in histoy can achieve sales like that after staring off so bad, i'm not even asking for 2 million, i'm asking for 1.5, its no even about bias but looking at sales trends you can easily see mass bundled games can get  a boost of 1.5- 2 million 



 

Gears of War 3

Global Total as of 23rd Feb 2013 (units): 5.78m
Platform: Xbox 360
Developer: Epic Games Genre: Shooter

 

 

Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception

Global Total as of 23rd Feb 2013 (units): 5.70m
Platform: PlayStation 3
Developer: Naughty Dog Genre: Action

updated



Come back next week when we compare Halo to little big planet.



lt_dan_27 said:

Come back next week when we compare Halo to little big planet.

Why would you compare those two - what do they have in common?



<a href="https://psnprofiles.com/fauzman"><img src="https://card.psnprofiles.com/2/fauzman.png" border="0"></a>