So the target casual audience isn't owned by the hardcore move one.

Maybe with age comes wisdom, but I have learned not to take Rol seriously when he posts something like this.

Basically, the gist of the argument is that games are better in high-definition and without motion controls. The Wii was a standard definition console with motion controls. Therefore, any game that was good/great on the Wii could have been better/even better on another console.

What is clear is that today, somewhere between 3/5s and 2/3s of US households have HD TVs -- and that is the highest rate in the world. Thus, if you make something for HD, you probably have only half a market. (Ironically, in mid-2010, only one-fifth of all US TV viewing was done in HD, meaning a lot of money was being spent for not a lot of results). In other words, HD is not universal, so wishing for it cuts who can enjoy it.

Mike from Morgantown

Which is funny because my 360 copy of MW3 says:
Aim Assist - Disabled (which is how a play all of my shooters)

It's true though that you can't disable it in all games, but having played a lot of FPS on my 360 I can safely say that in at least 80% of all games you can turn it off. It's auto disabled in the multiplayer modes anyway.

Doesn't work that way at all.   As I said, target locks only lock the camera in a single position (usually focused on the target.   But a bounding box is not taken into account when you have a target lock (meaning you can point all over the screen with no camera movement).   So matter what size you adjust the bounding box, it's irrelevant because the bounding box dimensions are ignored under a target lock.

Prove me wrong with a video clip.

Hang on a minute.  Are you trying to tell me that with a dual analog set up, you can turn your character, move the camera and aim all independantly?   Explain to me again how you obtain 3 independant axial motions from 2 analog sticks.   Is not the right analog stick mapped to both camera and aiming concurrently?  As in not independant?

aren't you forgetting that HD games can also be played on SD TVs ?
In fact only a few games are difficult to play on SD TVs and that are the games that use a small font like Dead Rising did.

So SD games run on SD&HD TVs and HD games run on SD&HD TVs. Isn't that 100% of the market ?

1. It's not disabled in multiplayer at all. 

2. Play a round, spin around with an enemy nearby.  As your cursor moves over the enemy, watch as your cursor slows.  That is visible proof aim assist is still on. Go try it.

3. Try it will all your games that allow you to turn aim assist off and it may surprise you how many still have a default level of aim assist going on.   Very few dual analog FPS's don't use any aim assist.   Want some developers to ask about it?  I can name you a few.

Here's a decent video regarding it.   I know it's for MW2, not 3, but the same aiming system was used.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnWWmfakFFQ&feature=related

Technically all of them could have looked better on ps3

You must have missed my post on the top of this pyramid. I've never disagreed about that.

Apparently nobody sent you the memo, it has already been debated to death on vgchartz and is pretty much accepted as fact that IR controls make dual analogs look primitive at best for fps. The reason being have already been stated by many on this thread. If DA is your own personal preference their is no problem with but don't try to pass your  opinion as fact.

How can that be a fact when it's a matter of opinions?

I'll give you another try.