Nice start. But I don't think it should be limited to sub $40 USD games because it doesn't really apply to people outside of USA (like yours truly), plus I think gamers would prefer spending a little more now and getting a quality game then the ones I've suggested be removed.
Because of that I'd add, Rainbow Six Vegas, GRAW2, Bioshock, Mass Effect, Virtua Fighter 5, Virtua Tennis 3, Madden 08 and Lost Planet.
I'd take out NFS, Test Drive, Ridge Racer, Earth Defense Force and maybe even Overlord because those games aren't that good (or good at all).










