By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Rate the Three Big Video Game Companies!

 

Which hardware manufacturer pleased you the most this gen?

Microsoft 30 15.54%
 
Nintendo 45 23.32%
 
Sony 67 34.72%
 
They all had their ups and downs 37 19.17%
 
None 2 1.04%
 
See results 9 4.66%
 
Step aside stupid poll! 2 1.04%
 
Total:192
badgenome said:

- Sony: 10/10 because all they have is nothing, really, but that's pretty good.

Lol

I'm not going to make a very detailed post, great ones by the1 and basilzero. I'm just going to state that I enjoy the most of playing with my friends, I'm a sucker for local multiplayer. I play both casual games, and the ones not so casual. The Wii is just the most suited console for me, bought it without any regret. I can't say the same thing about my PS3, but its ok, I'll find something good for it :).

However, if we are going to rate the companies I must say that Nintendo did a fantastic job, pulling out a decent console that caters a large audience and would be enough for the traditional Nintendo fan. I mean, most people argue that it didn't reach for the support of the 3rd parties, but bs, just look at the Gamecube -.- On the downside, they could've made more games in the late life. But, I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt and assume they were using all their resources on R&D for the 3DS and the next home console.

Now, about Microsoft. I've never owned one of their consoles, and I don't think I will. But, one must admit that the X360 had an incredible performance compared to the Xbox. The fail rate at the beggining is....just...wrong. But, well, people tell me that most of them were covered with the warranty. Then again, great performance, they are going to have a really solid start for next gen.

At last, Sony. Oh well, one can fell bad for these guys, you know market leaders for two generations, then... well just 'meh'. Its like they could've never existed this gen and pretty much nothing would've been missed. Even Final Fantasy went multiplattform. They are going to have a really hard start for next gen, not really sure how long do they have after Microsoft launches their next console, and not sure if they will have the resources to have a strong launch. So, quite dissapointing performance.

Sorry for using another approach, but as I don't own a x360, and I only have a couple of games for my ps3, my gamer view wouldve been quite biased ;)



Around the Network
brendude13 said:
BasilZero said:
enrageorange said:

No Wii or PSP score because I don't own those systems.

360
Pros
A few amazing exclusives
Best controller ever made
Great online 
older games still have very active communities
Cons
Kinect
you need to pay to play online
Score
8/10

PS3
Pros
Huge variety of exclusives
Free online
Move is awsome
Cons
Majority of exclusives aren't anything special(IMO)
No valkaria chronicles sequel
dualshock controller is god awful
Score
7/10

Nintendo DS
Pros
Best library of games this gen
great battery life
Cons
Most games don't take advantage of the hardware
Score
9/10


Why do you hate the dualshock o.O?

Because he's using it wrong, he needs to use it like I do.

ive tried and it just doesnt fit. How on earth do you manage to shove it in...

But to answer the serious question it is because the controller is far too small and the analogs are in a bad position. When i was 8 playing on my playstation one the controller was fine, but now its just uncomfortable to hold. My hands aren't freakishly huge or anything, its just uncomfortable to me.



Fun fact: After changing the thread title to "the three big video game giants" instead of "the big three" the Sony support increased significantly in the poll :P I honestly wonder why..?



IIIIITHE1IIIII said:
Fun fact: After changing the thread title to "the three big video game giants" instead of "the big three" the Sony support increased significantly in the poll :P I honestly wonder why..?

Maybe more Sony Fans gravitate to longer names? They should start using that as a marketing stunt. 



enrageorange said:

No Wii or PSP score because I don't own those systems.

360
Pros
A few amazing exclusives
Best controller ever made
Great online 
older games still have very active communities
Cons
Kinect
you need to pay to play online
Score
8/10

PS3
Pros
Huge variety of exclusives
Free online
Move is awsome
Cons
Majority of exclusives aren't anything special(IMO)
No valkaria chronicles sequel
dualshock controller is god awful
Score
7/10

Nintendo DS
Pros
Best library of games this gen
great battery life
Cons
Most games don't take advantage of the hardware
Score
9/10


Whats wrong with kinect?



Yay!!!

Around the Network
Reasonable said:

MS

First 360 console - terrible for me. Too hot, too loud, too unreliable, no WiFi, terrible disk tray. The largest power brick I briefly considered having in my house before thinking better of it. Good controller and at least they packed in a headset. 4/10

360 Slim - great console. Nice design, good USB placement, quiet, better disk tray, good wifi, smaller power brick (still too big IMHO but at least they tried) and seems very reliable. 9/10

Software - exclusives decent but not enough for me. I know MS pushes safe bet big titles over variety for the most part but I like to risk trying new stuff vs sticking to a few titles. 7/10 (9/10 if you bring in third party efforts).

Controllers - 8.5/10 for their gamepad. Nice to use but drops a point and a half for the D-Pad and the use of batteries with a horribly big and badly positioned (at least for my fingers) battery case. Kinect 7/10. Great device, but for me too limiting for games. Great for voice commands and menu use though. Needs a Wand IMHO to really be useful.

Online - 9.5/10. The gold standard really. Lots of features and a very good service. Stuff like Facebook should be available to Silver though (I say this as a Gold user but I think Silver get's shafted a bit).

Summary - a good gen overall for MS, particularly for me once they got past RROD and the original 360 design.

Sony

Fat PS3 - great console. Nice design, great feature set (I'm basing this on the PS2 compatible versions) and broad support for digital and physical media thanks to the card reader and Blu-Ray. Ran quiet and didn't get too hot. No power brick (trumped even the Wii in that regard). Only negative was it should have had 2 USB at front and 2 at back instead of all 4 to the front. 9.5/10 (I loved my fat PS3 - it was a pity I killed it myself)

Slim PS3 - very good console but oddly I'd argue a step back. Probably saved Sony's bacon but the feature set was cut back and 2 USB is a bit tight really given the amount of other stuff Sony in theory wanted you to hook up to it. Still at least it's quiet and reliable. 8.5/10.

Software - lots of exclusives, some great and some crap but lots of variety. 8.5/10 (9.5/10 if you bring in third party)

Controllers - Sixaxxis was too light and lacked rumble. 8/10. Dualshock 3 corrected all that and remains a better fit for my hand. 9.5/10. Move - works great and seems able to support a variety of gameplay types. 9/10

Online - very good now but not quite matching Live. 8.5/10 (9/10 in if you Plus and use the discounts)

Summary - doing okay now but boy did they start the gen in a terrible way. Pity the fat PS3 with full PS2 support was too costly to make and thereby too costly to afford - because purely as an electronics device it was definitely the best console this gen IMHO (I mean on its own just to be double clear - i.e. purely for what it contained separate from games)

Nintendo (going to make this one shorter)

Wii is a great little console that launched with the best integrated motion control package. Works great and is easy to use. But the online was horribly weak and personally I felt it should have played DVDs. As HD TVs became the norm I also felt it was underpowered vs the resolution of my TV. 8.5/10

Summary - the little console that went big but ran out of steam first.

You also forgot to include that Xbox controllers have built in mic jacks. Resulting n cheap FIRST PARTY mics. 



Yay!!!

I suppose my very rough ratings would be--

Sony) 8.5
Nintendo) 6.5
Microsoft) 7



           

First, badgenome won the thread by far.
Now, ratings:

Hardware:
Wii: 6/10, I'm not really angry about he lack of HD, but very few features.
PS3: 10/10, hurts to admit it.
360: 8/10, for the early problems.

Software: (My opinion, get over it)
Wii: 9/10, 2006-2010 was very, very good, afterwards, not so much, abysmal third party support. Gamecube still rules
PS3: 8/10, I liked a lot of PS3 exclusives, and the support was excelent.
360: (Bias on) 1/10, not a single exclusive that interests me or I liked. (Bias off)

Online:
Wii: 3/10, no explaination needed.
PS3: 9/10, it was fun playing online.
360: 5/10, it may have been better, but I wouldn't waste a cent on paying for online.

Classic Controller:
Wii: 8/10, comfortable, but doesn't support GC.
PS3: 7/10, classic.
360: 4/10, uncomfortable.

Motion:
Wii: 8/10, creative, WM+ didn't get support.
PS3: 7/10, pretty cool.
360: 4/10, fun, gets cheesy after a short while.

Overall: (Not an average)
Wii: 7.5/10 (A ton of potential, but Nintendo killed it)
PS3: 7/10 (A ton of efford from Sony)
360: 2/10 (Maybe it's because of the too-western appeal, but I totally dislike the 360 and the whole library)



"Overall: (Not an average)
Wii: 7.5/10 (A ton of potential, but Nintendo killed it)
PS3: 7/10 (A ton of efford from Sony)
360: 2/10 (Maybe it's because of the too-western appeal, but I totally dislike the 360 and the whole library)"

I totally agree with the underlined, bloded, and italic part of that. 



IIIIITHE1IIIII said:
Kynes said:
d21lewis said:

I won't assign a number. I'll just say:

360: Easily my most played console this gen. Got it in 2007 and I'm probably getting close to 200 games on it if you count XBL titles. An amazing console by a company I had no faith in whatsoever.   If I could only own one console this gen, the 360 would be it.

Wii: (purchased in 2007) So many unique experiences and so much fun. No other console has given me as many face to face fun social experiences as the Wii. I was born and bred playing side by side with other gamers. I'm afraid that those days may be done with online taking over like it has. I'm glad the Wii gave me so many good memories. I'll cherish them forever.

PS3: (Purchased in 2008) I probably spent more time with my jaw dropped in awe with the PS3 more than any of the other two. When the PS3 was at its best (Heavy Rain, God of War), nothing else mattered. A lot of games that I simply could not play anywhere else makes the PS3 a winner in my book.

Kudos to the "Big 3". My expectations were blown away time and again, this gen. To think, at the end of the sixth gen, I planned on giving up gaming. Now, I'm a bigger gamer than ever.

Thank God we still have gamers like you, and not everyone is a partisan.

Well, the poll suggests that at least more than 17% aren't partisan. And I don't think I can see any serious user here who is.


I'm not a serious user?