By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Star Wars Kinect Looks Beyond Terrible

Tagged games:

Mr Puggsly said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Mr Puggsly said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:


In Microsoft's "Kinect for the Core" campaign this is actually one of the games they are aiming to suck us in with as a core option. The Wii has more aptitude than the Kinect without having to water down everything and put it on rails. Microsoft is leaving these devs with an extremely hard task to prove. Quite frankly, I feel sorry for them. 

This is what I see in my head (LOL):

Microsoft: Hello Lucas Arts, we bought this thing we named Kinect from Prime Sense, and we dabbled with it a little. What we want to do is make a blockbuster Star Wars game for it?

Lucas Arts: Ok.......how?

Microsoft: Just do it, we'll publish it. 

Lucas Arts: Ok... its your money. 

You feel sorry for them? All they have to do is deliver a half decent game and it could potentially sell a few million. I don't think they need your pity.


Dont get me wrong bro, if we're talking casuals you wont hear an argument from me, but if you're campaigning that the core will salivate over this shit you're just crazy. Microsoft is campaigning this as well as a couple of other games to get the cores attention, but the most that can be come up with is voice command on Mass Effect and controls for Ghost Recon which will definitely be second to the controller and barely an option. The casuals? If they even touch those games good luck. 

In my opinion, the core Kinect campaign isn't a genuine effort to appeal to core gamers per se. It just showcases the Kinect library offers more than dance and party games. These core Kinect titles help broaden the audience but clearly they're designed to appeal to Kinect's primarily casual audience.

You're so concerned with Kinect as a core device but that's not the audience is was designed for. Kinect was designed to appeal to casual audiences and its been a massive success at bringing casual gamers to the 360. It doesn't matter if Kinect ever appeals to core gamers, its already been a far bigger success than anticipated.


This is why I use the term substance. When one says Kinect for core gamers per se you must prove it in the controls. We all know the cinematics are covered but when it comes down to its just  empty body tracking and rails. The tech can work, its just too soon. Rise of Nightmare is a good example of what Kinect attempts to do on its own but fails to do without controls. It gives me hope for the future, just not with this level of Kinect tech. Maybe another version of it. By this time any of the console providers would've found the tech to properly figure it out. People are questioning as well whether Ryse was pushed back to next gen. We will never know, but not one game showcased anything on par with what Microsoft is boasting. There is a list of games and you can look them up which Microsoft plans to draw the core and they will almost all be a joke to the core. If Microsoft created the tech themselves they would know what it is capable of instead of putting devs credibility on the line.



Around the Network

This game does look like ass but most Kinect titles don't look much better anyway this game is mostly made to sell the Star Wars bundles so I doubt it had much of a budget and Lucas Arts just half assed this.



Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.



 WII Code: 1732 3363 1704 6441

mitlar37 said:
Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.

The move can do voice commands. The Kinect doesnt have that over the move either, try again. Its Microsoft paying for voice recognition to be exclusive.



S.T.A.G.E. said:
mitlar37 said:
Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.

The move can do voice commands. The Kinect doesnt have that over the move either, try again. Its Microsoft paying for voice recognition to be exclusive.


I havent really seen Move in action (in terms of voice commands). I know because my friend owns one and im intending to buy it.... well... this comming christmas.  



Yay!!!

Around the Network

Quite honestly I really didn't see much other then the modes...People are bashing this title, because they want it to be a horrible title.

Now I am not saying this is going to be good. But, when people are already talking about control and how horrible it is....You could not tell from that video how responsive the controls will be.

I dislike the 2 hosts, but that dosen't mean Kinect star Wars will be a terrible game. This game may just end up being terrible, but what people are saying about the game after watching maybe 1 min. of video with 2 horrible hosts is a joke....

People need to wait until something more concrete comes out..... I think after, viewing that video way too many people are jumping to a conclusion without the due process....



Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
mitlar37 said:
Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.

The move can do voice commands. The Kinect doesnt have that over the move either, try again. Its Microsoft paying for voice recognition to be exclusive.


I havent really seen Move in action (in terms of voice commands). I know because my friend owns one and im intending to buy it.... well... this comming christmas.  

 Heres the specs. The mic is there and its powerful, Its just that no one has assigned a job to it. As I said Microsoft markets their products properly in the US.
http://www.develop-online.net/features/819/Full-Tech-Specs-Playstation-Move



S.T.A.G.E. said:
Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
mitlar37 said:
Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.

The move can do voice commands. The Kinect doesnt have that over the move either, try again. Its Microsoft paying for voice recognition to be exclusive.


I havent really seen Move in action (in terms of voice commands). I know because my friend owns one and im intending to buy it.... well... this comming christmas.  

 Heres the specs. The mic is there and its powerful, Its just that no one has assigned a job to it. As I said Microsoft markets their products properly in the US.
http://www.develop-online.net/features/819/Full-Tech-Specs-Playstation-Move


I mean, if Move have such "powerful" mic. Why dont they fully implement it to the ps3 system like the Xbox has with the kinect. And believe me, it works flawlessly. 

If Move have the tech, why does Sony ignore it? You get what i mean? 

Maybe, MS already has its voice recognition tech plus a voice "reg" library updated to the kinect it self? Why Move doesnt? 



Yay!!!

Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
mitlar37 said:
Lol @ MS Haters. So far the gimmick called Kinect has sold how much? And have fun pulling up your radial menu in ME3 for combat actions and conversations while I'm using voice commands.

The move can do voice commands. The Kinect doesnt have that over the move either, try again. Its Microsoft paying for voice recognition to be exclusive.


I havent really seen Move in action (in terms of voice commands). I know because my friend owns one and im intending to buy it.... well... this comming christmas.  

 Heres the specs. The mic is there and its powerful, Its just that no one has assigned a job to it. As I said Microsoft markets their products properly in the US.
http://www.develop-online.net/features/819/Full-Tech-Specs-Playstation-Move



I mean, if Move have such "powerful" mic. Why dont they fully implement it to the ps3 system like the Xbox has with the kinect. And believe me, it works flawlessly. 

If Move have the tech, why does Sony ignore it? You get what i mean? 

Maybe, MS already has its voice recognition tech plus a voice "reg" library updated to the kinect it self? Why Move doesnt? 

Truthfully dude, I dont know, but the voice recognition can spot your position in a room and provide echo cancellation so it can recognize commands. The fact that Kinect has three cameras instead of just one is where it has the edge just as a camera. The Move uses controllers to control its depth instead of infrared cams. Commands can be programmed into the move, but thats up to them. The tech is there, its just up to them to use it. The Move is a ball of gaming potential and I will have it when it has enough supported games, but I am def a fan of the tech. Kinect is also good, but much better at gathering casuals at my dorms. Tons of girls at my dorm who bought an Xbox solely for Kinect and Dance Central. I swear if I was to tell them about something else they would have a heart attack. Fun game though.



Carl2291 said:

Alright. Is this game a sick joke?

I hope it is.

https://www.youtube.com/v/nZ4wypo3vUU

I've got a bad feeling about this.