I think that with best graphics they took PC games into account in which case crysis 2 and battlefield 3 were clearly a lot better looking.
I don't see any other catagories that uncharted 3 clearly should have won. There was just a lot of competition this year. Yes personally someone might prefer uncharted to gears as a shooter, or to battlefield 3 for competitive multiplayer, or to portal 2 for best ps3 game, but its not like uncharted was the obvious winner of any of those catagories to everyone.
The only thing that bothers me is multiplatform games are winning best games on a specific console. They shouldn't be nominated period. Why make a best 360 and best ps3 game catagory when both have nearly identical nominees. That should be reserved for only exclusives and MAYBE I would understand if they included a game that was clearly significantly better on one of the two platforms, like bayonetta on the 360 was last year.
Yeah I know the competition was stiff and all but I just think Uncharted 3 deserved something. It's an amazing game after all.
I agree with you about multiplatform games winning best games, and like in "Best PS3 game"'s case, no exclusives even nominated.