By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Gamespot GOTY - Editor's Choice winners are in

Tagged games:

enrageorange said:
pezus said:
They gave a lot of games awards, but nothing for Uncharted 3...

I think that with best graphics they took PC games into account in which case crysis 2 and battlefield 3 were clearly a lot better looking.

I don't see any other catagories that uncharted 3 clearly should have won. There was just a lot of competition this year. Yes personally someone might prefer uncharted to gears as a shooter, or to battlefield 3 for competitive multiplayer, or to portal 2 for best ps3 game, but its not like uncharted was the obvious winner of any of those catagories to everyone.

The only thing that bothers me is multiplatform games are winning best games on a specific console. They shouldn't be nominated period. Why make a best 360 and best ps3 game catagory when both have nearly identical nominees. That should be reserved for only exclusives and MAYBE I would understand if they included a game that was clearly significantly better on one of the two platforms, like bayonetta on the 360 was last year.

Yeah I know the competition was stiff and all but I just think Uncharted 3 deserved something. It's an amazing game after all. 

I agree with you about multiplatform games winning best games, and like in "Best PS3 game"'s case, no exclusives even nominated.



Around the Network
worldlyfall said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

 

OMG they didn't nominate uncharted 3 and they gave demon souls GOTY but not uncharted 2? BLASPHMEY! There is only on logical explanation for this evil deed they hate uncharted!

 

-_- seriously, so much butthurt here. 

 

They probably don't hate Uncharted but I guess they like them less than the average video game site.



pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.



Mirson said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.



pezus said:
Mirson said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

So whats the point your trying to make Gamespot is not a cerditable site because they dont ride the Uncharted bandwagon? At least they are better than IGN and gametrailers. 



Around the Network
worldlyfall said:
pezus said:
Mirson said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

So whats the point your trying to make Gamespot is not a cerditable site because they dont ride the Uncharted bandwagon? At least they are better than IGN and gametrailers. 

No point actually. Just pointing out that the lack of recognition for Uncharted on GS is sorely disappointing



pezus said:
worldlyfall said:
pezus said:
Mirson said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

So whats the point your trying to make Gamespot is not a cerditable site because they dont ride the Uncharted bandwagon? At least they are better than IGN and gametrailers. 

No point actually. Just pointing out that the lack of recognition for Uncharted on GS is sorely disappointing


Oh okay. 



pezus said:
Mirson said:

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

Maybe the other editors thought other games were more deserving than U3. They even stated that it wasn't easy eliminating Uncharted 3 from the nomination list. And I would agree with them.



Mirson said:
pezus said:
Mirson said:

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

Maybe the other editors thought other games were more deserving than U3. They even stated that it wasn't easy eliminating Uncharted 3 from the nomination list. And I would agree with them.

I think it's pretty weak to consider Outland more worthy than Uncharted 3. A PSN game...



worldlyfall said:
pezus said:
Mirson said:
pezus said:
osamanobama said:
also Uncharted 3 not only got omitted from GOTY and PS3 GOTY, but most laughably of all it got omitted from
Best Graphics. what a joke, and Crysis and Forza make the list but Uncharted 3 doesnt?
lulz.

at least the got one ting right, and put Killzone 3 on the list. strangely most sites seem to be missing it, even though it is the 2nd best graphical game of not only this year but out of all time on console, and by some margin.
graphics of the year lists without Uncharted 3 and Killzone 3 are laughable. (especially without Uncharted 3)
poor killzone is alsways over shadowed by Uncharted.

Lol, hadn't noticed that before. They just look like a bunch of Uncharted haters. In 2009 they gave Demon's Souls GOTY over Uncharted 2, and probably other awards over it, can't remember.

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

So whats the point your trying to make Gamespot is not a cerditable site because they dont ride the Uncharted bandwagon? At least they are better than IGN and gametrailers. 


Sorry but omitting Uncharted 3 from the nominations while including Dirt 3 and Outland is simply ludicrous. There is no way a professional journalist can justify such nonsense.