By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Numbers That MS Needs To Pull To Tie The PS3 For 2011. And Why I Think It Is Now Impossible.

 

Will The 360 Be Able To Pull It Off?

The Kinect Will Rule The ... 220 27.92%
 
It Will Be Close, But The... 241 30.58%
 
No Way. The PS3 Will Be ... 270 34.26%
 
What Are You Talking Abou... 56 7.11%
 
Total:787
sales2099 said:
In the end, MS chose profit over their bold statement to sell more then PS3 in 2011.

But hey, they are making a nice profit with the same prices since 2008 (!) where as Sony is bleeding red ink.

All signs point to price drops in 2012 guaranteed, 2012 will be the year the 360 widens the gap.....and profits doing so.

Then I suggest they stop talking about being #1 WW in each NPD since June.  Also, when the numbers aren't going your way, change the argument to profits. 



Around the Network

I think sony will still keep the sales lead this year...but i'm guessing MS will close the gap by about a million in these next 7 to 8 weeks.

Also if MS wanted to they could say the sell more per capita WW...but that would come across as cheap PR.



thismeintiel said:
sales2099 said:
In the end, MS chose profit over their bold statement to sell more then PS3 in 2011.

But hey, they are making a nice profit with the same prices since 2008 (!) where as Sony is bleeding red ink.

All signs point to price drops in 2012 guaranteed, 2012 will be the year the 360 widens the gap.....and profits doing so.

Then I suggest they stop talking about being #1 WW in each NPD since June.  Also, when the numbers aren't going your way, change the argument to profits. 


lol like Sony never changed its agenda.....

At least MS is making a decent profit and at least holding its own without a price cut



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

sales2099 said:


lol like Sony never changed its agenda.....

At least MS is making a decent profit and at least holding its own without a price cut

Here's the thing that is puzzling to me:

MS sold 960'000 Boxes last week. Most of these boxes were price reduced, essentially selling at zero shop markup. Most were sold with $50/$100 vouchers. So let's assume an average of $50 voucher per Box, that makes roughly $50mio _somebody_ has lost last week. I really can't figure out why losing so much money is sane business practise? Those 800'000 sold boxes on bf may sound incredible, but it is simply 800'000 boxes NOT sold (at a profit) around Chritsmas..

And please stop that silly "no pricecut" argument. USA =/= TheWorld. Over here, XBoxes have always been (considerably) cheaper than PS3s (and Kinect has just seen its fourth price cut in a year...)



XBoxes have always been (considerably) cheaper than PS3s huh
why can't you stop Europe=world first



Around the Network

Below



What the original poster and many others " don't get" is it really doesn't matter if Sony surpasses Ms in consoles sold.  The ps3's price was so much higher then the cost to make it on release.. That Sony literally lost 4.9 billion USD..as of 2009 ( in comparison, last generation - MS lost 4.2 Billion on start-up cost on the original Xbox )... In mid 2010 Sony began making a small profit on PS3's.. Of course a year of marginal profit doesnt remake all the billions they lost.. Billions that were made from the good old PS2 days.. Recently as everyone knows the PS3 price drop put them back in the 'RED' .. Sony announced a loss of 350 million  US dollars from the PS3 in one quarter alone ( www.vgchartz.com/article/88359/sony-loses-350m-in-july-sept-2011-ps3-shipments-within-2m-of-x360/ ). ... Sony could surpass MS in consoles sold.. For them it would only be a 'moral victory' as MS has been out of the red for years now.  Even considering losses on all those "free repairs" MS did on rrod consoles - MS will have positive cash flow this generation ( money put in the bank ) while Sony will not overall .. The 360 has only been profitable about 3 yrs.. But they weren't ever losing $400 dollars per console or even $300... MS also had the millions each quarter from Xbox live while Sony only recently offered a subscription service very comparable to XB live Gold in which they can make some extra cash.. MS has also made more from games.. Not just from selling a little more, but also from cheaper cost.. It's only about 10 cents per DVD... While it cost dollars for a single blueray disc .. From that stand point alone MS has made Hundreds of Millions more this generation on games alone thanks to selling more games and lower operating cost.  From a strictly financial point of view.. The PS3 is in last place this generation... it has done the opposite of what the PS2 did financially for Sony.  On the other hand the Xbox 360 did the opposite of the original Xbox.. It's outsold the original Xbox by two fold so far, the 360 has also outsold itself every year it's been out ( it's already again beat last years sales - against itself - for the 6th year in a row) .. This is why they won't release another console next year.  As long as its still selling hotter each year ( aka the PS2 ) they know it would just hurt their wallets.  This is why the PS2 lasted so long!  Positive Cash and they were number 1 !  Sony can't control the market the same way with a console that has lost so much money - and continues to.... This is why if your a Sony stockholder you're probably looking forward to a PS4 release.  Why?  I'm sure this time Sony won't dare release a console at such a big loss.. It'll likely be much cheaper then the PS3 was off the shelf as well.. Yeah the PS2 was sold in a perfect storm.... It was released nearly a year before an underpowered Nintendo console.. And released way ahead of a console no one really knew would exist with Xbox 1... Throw in the fact the PS2 was the only console then to play DVD ( the  already established format- unlike bluray).. At the time it barely cost more to by a PS2 then a Premium DVD player.. So many consumers bought a PS2 knowing they could watch movies and the kids could game... Right now if your the Xbox division President you're getting patted on the back and getting a fat bonus for the holidays.. The guy who lowered the Ps3 price might not even have a job.. At minimum he got some serious @zz chewing.. The PS3 profit margin was so slim that the devaluing of the Yen cost Sony 350 million US dollars ( roughly 54 billion yen ) in the last 4 months alone..  So you see even if MS would come in last place in number of consoles sold they won't be too worried.. They've so far doubled the user base since last gen ( Sony has has 1/2'd theirs ) .. 



Microsoft just sold over 1 million consoles in a week, that surely helps them



drkohler said:
sales2099 said:


lol like Sony never changed its agenda.....

At least MS is making a decent profit and at least holding its own without a price cut

Here's the thing that is puzzling to me:

MS sold 960'000 Boxes last week. Most of these boxes were price reduced, essentially selling at zero shop markup. Most were sold with $50/$100 vouchers. So let's assume an average of $50 voucher per Box, that makes roughly $50mio _somebody_ has lost last week. I really can't figure out why losing so much money is sane business practise? Those 800'000 sold boxes on bf may sound incredible, but it is simply 800'000 boxes NOT sold (at a profit) around Chritsmas..

And please stop that silly "no pricecut" argument. USA =/= TheWorld. Over here, XBoxes have always been (considerably) cheaper than PS3s (and Kinect has just seen its fourth price cut in a year...)


Still at a profit,  Microsoft had to have been making a profit somewhere to have lowered the price.  That is like saying the first 20 million or more PS3 sales don't count as sony took a loss on them.  Xbox still wins if you factor that statement in.  If you want to get real serious, than the Wii wins hands down as it was never sold by Nintendo for less than a profit.  The parts to make the consoles have gotten cheaper, yet console prices have only dropped by a little bit.  Microsoft also puts a premium on HDD prices, which even with inflated HDD prices is still crazy.  So they've made a profit.  Take the Sony goggles off.  All of the big three made decent sales this week. 



Where I am the 250GB Xbox 360 sells for £189ish and the 320GB PS3 with Karate Kid Blu Ray sells for £199ish.

The 360 still almost doubles the PS3 in sales.

I guess when it comes to profits made MS take it hands down. The UK has become completely 360 dominated for consoles.