By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Greatest Industry Icon Tournament: Shigeru Miyamoto Vs. Hideo Kojima

Miyamoto-sama!



Around the Network
Carl2291 said:
Kojima, because he doesn't milk the same franchise over and over again.
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA

I heard he worked on a few Metal Gear games.

YearGameCredited asSystems
DirectorProducerWriterGame designer
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA
YearGameCredited asSystems
DirectorProducerWriterGame designer
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA


Carl2291 said:
Kojima, because he doesn't milk the same franchise over and over again.

Do you really think Miyamoto had a hand in EVERY Mario spinoff released?

On-Topic: I vote Kojima because he is losing



Kojima makes movies, Miyamoto makes games, so I'll go with Miyamoto.



 

 

 

Paul said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Shigeru Miyamoto hasn't wow'd me in over a decade, but Hideo Kojima made me take MGS4 because there was to much stealth and MGR is going to be so awesum so hands down its not Shigeru Miyamoto.


Hideo Kojima

It's the Greatest Industry Icon Tournament, not the who gives you the bigest hardon tournament. Only the biggest metal gear fanboys could possibly think that
Hideo Kojima is a bigger industry Icon. The vast majority of people have never heard of metal gear solid. You'd be hard pressed to find someone who has never heard of a Mario game.

you'd be better off saying MDJ you know nothing about the MGS franchise and you'd be right. i only play'd 30minutes of MGS4 before i took it back for VC!

re-read the post you quoted. better yet i'll say it again. Shigeru Miyamoto hasn't wow'd me in over a decade and if you ask me to name any other game that Kojima has made other then MGS then i'd have to google it meanning i have no idea.

i know Nintendo and thats the problem. and i'll continue to vote against everything Nintendo in this tournament. me and the N64 died together when the gamecube released.

next gen me and Nintendo are through. welcome me to Xbox720, and my return to PC cause the review system is broken and Nintendo proves it. thhat sentence means  N intendo has failed everyone. 



Around the Network

The winner of this tournament: Miyamoto.



 

Miyamoto. He has never stopped amazing me.



Shigeru because he's not attempting to make gaming movies.



Pixel Art can be fun.

Paul said:
Carl2291 said:
Kojima, because he doesn't milk the same franchise over and over again.
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA

I heard he worked on a few Metal Gear games.

YearGameCredited asSystems
DirectorProducerWriterGame designer
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA
YearGameCredited asSystems
DirectorProducerWriterGame designer
1987 Metal Gear Yes   Yes Yes 1987: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2, 2006: i-revo
1990 Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Yes   Yes   1990: MSX2, 2004: MP, 2005: PS2
1998 Metal Gear Solid Yes Yes Yes   1998: PS
1999 Metal Gear Solid: Integral Yes Yes Yes   1999: PS, 2000: Microsoft Windows
2000 Metal Gear: Ghost Babel   Yes     2000: GBC
2001 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Yes Yes Yes   2001: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2002 The Document of Metal Gear Solid 2 Yes Yes     2002: PS2
2002 Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance Yes Yes Yes   2002: Xbox, 2003: PS2, Microsoft Windows
2004 Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes   Yes Yes   2004: NGC
2004 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater Yes Yes Yes   2004: PS2, 2011: PS3, 360
2004 Metal Gear Acid   Yes     2004: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Acid 2   Yes     2005: PSP
2005 Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence Yes Yes Yes   2005: PS2
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel Yes Yes     2006: PSP
2006 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops   Yes Yes   2006: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid: Portable Ops Plus   Yes Yes   2007: PSP
2007 Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Desinee Yes Yes     2007: DVD
2008 Metal Gear Solid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Acid Mobile   Yes     2008: MP
2008 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots / Metal Gear Online Yes Yes Yes   2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Gene Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2008 Metal Gear Online: Meme Expansion   Yes     2008: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Online: Scene Expansion   Yes     2009: PS3
2009 Metal Gear Solid Touch   Yes     2009: iOS
2010 Metal Gear Arcade   Yes     2010: Arcade
2010 Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker Yes Yes Yes Yes 2010: PSP, PSP Go, 2011: PS3, 360
2011 Metal Gear Solid: HD Collection Yes Yes Yes   2011: PS3, 360, PSVITA
2011 Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D Yes Yes Yes   2011: 3DS
TBA Metal Gear Solid: Rising   Yes     2012: PS3, 360, Microsoft Windows, PSVITA




MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Paul said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Shigeru Miyamoto hasn't wow'd me in over a decade, but Hideo Kojima made me take MGS4 because there was to much stealth and MGR is going to be so awesum so hands down its not Shigeru Miyamoto.


Hideo Kojima

It's the Greatest Industry Icon Tournament, not the who gives you the bigest hardon tournament. Only the biggest metal gear fanboys could possibly think that
Hideo Kojima is a bigger industry Icon. The vast majority of people have never heard of metal gear solid. You'd be hard pressed to find someone who has never heard of a Mario game.

you'd be better off saying MDJ you know nothing about the MGS franchise and you'd be right. i only play'd 30minutes of MGS4 before i took it back for VC!

re-read the post you quoted. better yet i'll say it again. Shigeru Miyamoto hasn't wow'd me in over a decade and if you ask me to name any other game that Kojima has made other then MGS then i'd have to google it meanning i have no idea.

i know Nintendo and thats the problem. and i'll continue to vote against everything Nintendo in this tournament. me and the N64 died together when the gamecube released.

next gen me and Nintendo are through. welcome me to Xbox720, and my return to PC cause the review system is broken and Nintendo proves it. thhat sentence means  N intendo has failed everyone. 

I like cheese more than Miyamoto but that doesn't make cheese a bigger videogame indusrty icon. Maybe they should run a who do you dislike the most contest for you. Your answer would make more sense that way.