By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - American Atheists' 9/11 Memorial Lawsuit Crosses the Line of Decency

Two days after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, smoke was still rising from the twisted and burnt material that used to be the World Trade Center.  Untold numbers of first responders from around the country were converging on New York City to help look for survivors trapped in the rubble, and the nation as a whole was still somewhere between fear and unmitigated anger: somewhere between “woe is me” and “woe is thee.”
 
And that’s when workers came upon a 20-foot section of steel beams that the heat and pressures of the attacks had left shaped as a cross.  It was standing upright in the mangled mess, and for those laboring in the carnage and the untold numbers of family and friends waiting to receive news on the safety of their loved ones, the cross provided a moment of transcendence.
 
Throughout the months of cleanup that followed, that cross “served as a symbol of hope for many devastated by the worst terrorist attack in our nation’s history,” according to Congressman J. Randy Forbes of Virginia.  It was, and continues to be, a commonly used symbol of sacrifice for all kinds of people: not just Christians.  And as such, it is simply a part of the history of the 9/11 attacks.
 
Because of this, the cross has been relocated in the 9/11 Memorial and Museum (which opens in 2012).  There it will be on display with a myriad of other artifacts and memorabilia linked to the Tuesday morning we won’t soon forget.
 
But if groups such as American Atheists get their way, the cross will not be in the museum when it opens.  In hopes of ensuring this, they have filed a lawsuit claiming the very presence of the cross has caused atheists to feel “dyspepsia, symptoms of depression, headaches, anxiety, and mental pain and anguish from the knowledge that they are made to feel officially excluded from the ranks of citizens who were directly injured by the 9/11 attack.”
 
In other words, because the two steel beams that happened to be standing after the smoke cleared were in the form of a cross, those two beams must be excluded from other 9/11 artifacts because of the way they make atheists feel, the feelings of the rest of the country notwithstanding.
 
Just as Easter and Christmas, though Christian in their roots, have become so mainstream as to be celebrated by Christians and non-Christians alike, so too, even secularized references to the cross as a symbol of suffering are ubiquitous.  Thus it is reasonable that the two steel beams which intersected to form a cross, by no intention or invention of man, have served as a rallying point for both religious and nonreligious persons since the September 11 attacks.
 
It’s disheartening that American Atheists has nothing better to do than fight to remove this focal point from the landscape of our nation’s memory.

 

http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=45640

 

Is anyone else not suprised by the slightest?



Around the Network

As an atheist i say they should get over it.



Not surprised, just a little pissed. What about the Muslims, Jews, Buddhists etc who were also killed in the attacks? You don't hear them bitching about the cross.



God did WTC



WHERE IS MY KORORINPA 3

Wow that is unbelievably pathetic.



Around the Network

Wow, seriously, atheists in the US are going overboard with EVERY little thing. From the pledge of allegiance, to the historic 10 commandment stone tablets that have been there for waaaaayyy too many years and now this. Seriously atheists should STFU. Noone is forcing them to convert to any of the hundreds of religions and cults out there. Like Dane Cook said once: I hope when that atheist guy dies, he becomes the fertilizer in that tree that gets cut down and taken to a factory, and when it finally gets cut smaller for use, it gets used as paper to print another fking bible!



Make games, not war (that goes for ridiculous fanboys)

I may be the next Maelstorm or not, you be the judge http://videogamesgrow.blogspot.com/  hopefully I can be more of an asset than a fanboy to VGC hehe.

As a non-Christian I say all symbology related to 9/11 is fine. If happenstance caused a couple of beams to take the shape of a cross and some people superstitiously found some solace or meaning in it, then the museum should have that piece of steel there.

I you feel threatened our cast out by the symbology that others hold dear then you will never feel part of any society unless you are in the majority group. And that's rather a pathetic world view for anyone. Being in a religious minority that is smaller than atheism in every western country I know what it is to be out of the mainstream but I also don't care that I'm different, actually I like it.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

melbye said:
As an atheist i say they should get over it.


also an atheist, also think they should get over it.  america ought to be about respecting everyones right to religion -- christians/whatever respecting me and me respecting them.  it's not about trying to ignore religion, it's about everyone acknowledging everyone else in a respectful way.  



the cross is not a secular symbol. and i have no idea about the actual lawsuit but this is definitely a biased article, so i cant actually judge whether or not the lawsuit is absurd.



"I like my steaks how i like my women.  Bloody and all over my face"

"Its like sex, but with a winner!"

MrBubbles Review Threads: Bill Gates, Jak II, Kingdom Hearts II, The Strangers, Sly 2, Crackdown, Zohan, Quarantine, Klungo Sssavesss Teh World, MS@E3'08, WATCHMEN(movie), Shadow of the Colossus, The Saboteur

That is balls, it's not like the museum is spreading the good news about Jesus, the "cross" was a symbolic formation that gives reverence to the event.