Man I loved Colours. One of the best Sonic games ever made and definatly the best one released this generation. Now I love 2D but I would also love to see a true sequal to Sonic Adventure quality wise. But I guess I'll have to do with the best 2D Sonic game in generations!

maybe i'm the black sheep around here but i didn't like colours. The 3D sections were few and too short, and they felt like connections between 2d sections. 2d sections were slow as hell and i didn't like the enphasis on the alien powers. it was short, and graphics were nowhere near as good as the storybook team's sonics.

it's not awful like unleashed or the black knight, but my favourite sonic this gen is still the secret rings. yes it was flawed, but it's the sonic that i enjoyed the most.

I also own Sonic and have for a while now, and I don't see it as anything more than a "good" game, definitely not a great one. The value is too low and the gameplay too shallow to make it anything better than that IMO. I don't really get all the hype, unless Sonic fans are a masochistic bunch who have come to expect utter garbage and actually pay for it on a regular basis.

Then again maybe I'm just not a big fan of this kind of game.

I feel exactly the same. It's a good game, but far far from great. To me it is over rated. The character designs, level designs and script is far from being great (with the latter far from being good). I won't say i didn't enjoy sonic, but it feels more like the a sonic "without errors" rather than an inspiring sonic game. God knows how bad the previous games were