By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Uncharted 3 beta vs Gears of War 3 beta?

dsage01 on 03 July 2011
o_O.Q said:
mendozahotness said:
Relatively speaking they are at equal stages of development

The Gears 3 beta ended over 6 weeks ago, it comes out a little over 5 weeks earlier than Uncharted 3.

how is that so? gears 3 was supposed to be out 3 months ago and had playable builds at last years E3 while uncharted was initially revealed at the end of last year

I thought Gears of War 3 was the most popular beta for the Xbox 360. I am sure a lot of people here must have played it other than me



Around the Network
dsage01 on 03 July 2011
Nsanity said:
Hynad said:
Nsanity said:
osamanobama said:
Nsanity said:

dsage01 Comparison mentions that Uncharted 3 dropped well below 20FPS so why not mention that? also i know its small bit off topic but some of these people arent blind as others.

http://forums.gametrailers.com/thread/uncharted-3-beta-impressions-/1228160
http://forums.naughtydog.com/t5/Multiplayer-Beta-Discussion/Initial-Uncharted-3-MP-Beta-Impressions/td-p/327095
http://forums.gametrailers.com/thread/uncharted-3--people-dissapoint/1228168
http://forums.gametrailers.com/thread/uc3-beta--disappointing/1229100
http://forums.naughtydog.com/t5/Multiplayer-Beta-Discussion/ND-has-ruined-what-made-U2-great/td-p/323891
http://forums.gametrailers.com/thread/disappointing-/1228629


wait... people are blinded if they love the uncharted beta?

are you scouring the net to just find things negative to say about uncharted. (going to sites you would never normally go to (naughtydog.com))

 

also any performance issues uncharted may have had was during the first several hours. which then got fixed by the subsuquent patch

Some of the forums members on Gametrailers and Naughtydog.com are far less delusional than a certain individual group we have on this site so would only make sense to post their arguably debatable impressions here.

Basically, what you are saying is that if anyone doesn't agree with the assumption that Gears 3 looks better, or that they don't like the game as much as some others, they are blind.  So in essence, anyone who likes something for what it is without finding unforgettable faultsin it is blind?  Or is it just that the side which you so choose, with your own known bias (Gears 3 and most things 360), is the only one that can't be considered blind?  

Hypocrisy much, eh?

Actually i have no problem with one person choosing or liking one game over the other, however i did point out few pages back that dsage01 was quick enough to rip into Gears about its tearing but failed to mentioning any of Uncharted flaws, why? because he is acting like Uncharted is on some higher plain and those links i posted from PS3 owners are almost the opposite of what the OP and others are saying so i apologise for acting like dick.

If you haven't read I said earlier in this post and also in the Offical Uncharted 3 beta thread by Ethomaz that Uncharted 3 had a whole bunch of connection problems. And in the begining it felt slow and buggy. Try to get more evidence before you blame anyone :)



o_O.Q on 03 July 2011
dsage01 said:
o_O.Q said:
mendozahotness said:
Relatively speaking they are at equal stages of development

The Gears 3 beta ended over 6 weeks ago, it comes out a little over 5 weeks earlier than Uncharted 3.

how is that so? gears 3 was supposed to be out 3 months ago and had playable builds at last years E3 while uncharted was initially revealed at the end of last year

I thought Gears of War 3 was the most popular beta for the Xbox 360. I am sure a lot of people here must have played it other than me

im confused how does what you said correlate with my comment? i was commenting on his statement about the stages of development for both games



dsage01 on 03 July 2011
o_O.Q said:
dsage01 said:
o_O.Q said:
mendozahotness said:
Relatively speaking they are at equal stages of development

The Gears 3 beta ended over 6 weeks ago, it comes out a little over 5 weeks earlier than Uncharted 3.

how is that so? gears 3 was supposed to be out 3 months ago and had playable builds at last years E3 while uncharted was initially revealed at the end of last year

I thought Gears of War 3 was the most popular beta for the Xbox 360. I am sure a lot of people here must have played it other than me

im confused how does what you said correlate with my comment? i was commenting on his statement about the stages of development for both games

sorry I meant to wirte this post somewhere else



kickazz113 on 06 July 2011

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho



Around the Network
smroadkill15 on 06 July 2011
kickazz113 said:

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho


I don't know about that. Maybe on the Vgchartz yes, but in the real world I'm pretty sure the Gears series has the Uncharted series beat in a popularity contest. If I looked up the number of Gears 3 beta players and compared them to uncharted 3 beta players I don't even think it would be close.  Just look at the pre-orders for both games. 



osamanobama on 06 July 2011
smroadkill15 said:
kickazz113 said:

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho


I don't know about that. Maybe on the Vgchartz yes, but in the real world I'm pretty sure the Gears series has the Uncharted series beat in a popularity contest. If I looked up the number of Gears 3 beta players and compared them to uncharted 3 beta players I don't even think it would be close.  Just look at the pre-orders for both games. 

you are right Gears is definitely bigger than Uncharted, but Uncharted is huge too.

i dont know how many people played the Gears beta, but 3 days ago Naughty Dog said over 600,000 unique players played in the beta, so obviously that number is bigger now, especially since the beta is now public



dsage01 on 06 July 2011
osamanobama said:
smroadkill15 said:
kickazz113 said:

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho


I don't know about that. Maybe on the Vgchartz yes, but in the real world I'm pretty sure the Gears series has the Uncharted series beat in a popularity contest. If I looked up the number of Gears 3 beta players and compared them to uncharted 3 beta players I don't even think it would be close.  Just look at the pre-orders for both games. 

you are right Gears is definitely bigger than Uncharted, but Uncharted is huge too.

i dont know how many people played the Gears beta, but 3 days ago Naughty Dog said over 600,000 unique players played in the beta, so obviously that number is bigger now, especially since the beta is now public

^ So in just 5 days 600k!! This looks like to beat Reach. Well maybe but how many players were in the Gears 3 beta. And do you have a link for the Uncharted 3 beta?



osamanobama on 06 July 2011
dsage01 said:
osamanobama said:
smroadkill15 said:
kickazz113 said:

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho


I don't know about that. Maybe on the Vgchartz yes, but in the real world I'm pretty sure the Gears series has the Uncharted series beat in a popularity contest. If I looked up the number of Gears 3 beta players and compared them to uncharted 3 beta players I don't even think it would be close.  Just look at the pre-orders for both games. 

you are right Gears is definitely bigger than Uncharted, but Uncharted is huge too.

i dont know how many people played the Gears beta, but 3 days ago Naughty Dog said over 600,000 unique players played in the beta, so obviously that number is bigger now, especially since the beta is now public

^ So in just 5 days 600k!! This looks like to beat Reach. Well maybe but how many players were in the Gears 3 beta. And do you have a link for the Uncharted 3 beta?

wow, ur optimistic. i wish Uncharted could Reach Reach's sales, but not gonna happen. 

I will be optimistic and say it will sell 6 million

anyway: http://ps3.ign.com/articles/118/1180460p1.html

IGN: Ballpark, how many people have played so far? 

Robert Cogburn: In the last week alone, since beta launch, we have had more than 600,000 unique people play the game! The team is quite stoked to see how many more people check out the game when it goes public on Tuesday, July 5. 



dsage01 on 06 July 2011
osamanobama said:
dsage01 said:
osamanobama said:
smroadkill15 said:
kickazz113 said:

there are actually more uncharted fan than gear fan tho


I don't know about that. Maybe on the Vgchartz yes, but in the real world I'm pretty sure the Gears series has the Uncharted series beat in a popularity contest. If I looked up the number of Gears 3 beta players and compared them to uncharted 3 beta players I don't even think it would be close.  Just look at the pre-orders for both games. 

you are right Gears is definitely bigger than Uncharted, but Uncharted is huge too.

i dont know how many people played the Gears beta, but 3 days ago Naughty Dog said over 600,000 unique players played in the beta, so obviously that number is bigger now, especially since the beta is now public

^ So in just 5 days 600k!! This looks like to beat Reach in amount of people playing the beta. Well maybe but how many players were in the Gears 3 beta. And do you have a link for the Uncharted 3 beta?

wow, ur optimistic. i wish Uncharted could Reach Reach's sales, but not gonna happen. 

I will be optimistic and say it will sell 6 million

anyway: http://ps3.ign.com/articles/118/1180460p1.html

IGN: Ballpark, how many people have played so far? 

Robert Cogburn: In the last week alone, since beta launch, we have had more than 600,000 unique people play the game! The team is quite stoked to see how many more people check out the game when it goes public on Tuesday, July 5. 

I meant to say something different. I just corrected that. But the real question is will it beat Gears of War 3's 1.29 million? I am starting to doubt it can reach Halo Reach's 2.7 million but it might just have a chance on Gears of War 3.