Poll added.

7/10 Slightly Better then Sony


Nintendo > Sony > Poop > MS

4/10

A combination of disgusted and dissapointed.

I was expecting Nintendo to have the best E3, guess I was wrong, very wrong.

I will post a full review of all the E3's. For me, KONAMI won, that his how dire these E3 conferences were.

6 out of 10, but they only will please people who buy Nintendo only products. I could be wrong.

I second that!! Mind blowing stuff! 

And i think they didnt give out Wii content because i don't think anyone would've cared!! O_o

7.5

Lot's of new games from original franchises i.e Mario kart/ssmb etc
Of the two handhelds the 3ds has by far the better line-up for this holiday.

Hardly any Wii stuff and no demo's of people doing some motion controller type things.

The only real downside i have is that i still have no clue what the new thing is....is it an add-on for Wii, is it a stand alone thing? For a reveal it was pretty awful. The graphics for it don't look on par with 360/PS3 which is strange because we already know both Sony and Microsoft are working on their next consoles and i think it is nailed on that the new 360 will be announced at the next E3.

Nintendo won E3 but only just. And not because of it's brilliance but because the other two sucked.

I didn't notice anything first party coming from Nintendo for the Wii U, they gotta be holding a lot back then. I mean seriously, no first party games for a new nintendo console??? They might give up the launch to give some love to third parties, but there are way too many questions that conference didn't answer...

6/10

Honestly, this is totally underwhelming.

I'm sure Nintendo will do something great with WiiU eventually, but this showing was lame. I was more excited for DKC Returns last year, and it was just a game... not a system... though practically nothing was REALLY shown,

Being nice, I'll give it a 5, just like the other two.

E3 sucked this year - all around and all 3.

7/10

The Good:

WiiU has great features, and sounds promising from a third party and online perspective. Loving the multi functionality of the controller. Third party footage confirms the system is at least on par with 360/PS3. Also was pleased to see that Zelda teaser, though I doubt it's from anything in game. The opening section on Zelda was good for a Zelda nut like me, very happy Four Swords will be free, that Link's Awakening is out soon and that Skyward Sword is coming at the end of the year. What little I saw of it looked excellent. 3DS was great, definitely getting Ocarina 3D, Super Mario 3D, Mario Kart and Kid Icarus this year, hoping Luigi's Mansion 2 will make it out too. Prospect of Smash Bros 3DS/WiiU made me wet myself a little.

The Bad:

No proper Skyward Sword trailer or date. No definite dates for 3DS titles. WiiU demonstration lacking any definite first party titles was deeply disappointing. Much as I love Zelda, they spent too long at the beginning of the conference talking about it. No Xenoblade or Last Story, and next to nothing said about Wii was frustrating and disappointing--why ignore it at E3? Why not show existing users some support?

Overall, I think Nintendo have 'won' E3, but they haven't satisfied me. It was a good show, but not great. They could--and should, as far as I'm concerned--have shown more. There weren't really many new first party announcements, only Luigi's Mansion 2 for 3DS and Four Swords (if that's actually a new Four Swords) for DSi. Everything else had been shown in some capacity before. I would be more satisfied with either another new 3DS or WiiU first party title, or localisation and dates for Last Story and Xenoblade. That conference was good, but it could have been longer and better.

9/10, because there was a bunch of sweet announcements, but it was nothing on last year's convention.