Id be cool with that. But that aint gonna happen =/

I would like an option for both. 

Some games are great for motion controls like FPS, but fighting games should never have them.

So "hardcore" gamers are satisfied with using a dual analog controller for the next 20 years?

Why would i want to play GTA 50 when there are slight changes to the overall experience? Count me out.

I would like to see Nintendo do something completely new - however I have a feeling they will go for some kind of Hybrid Motion/Classic controller.  

One idea I had was a controller that is configurable that allows you to remove the duel sticks to make it more streamlined for waving around in a sports game. 

None will substitute the other.

Both controls. Motion controls just proved without any doubt they are here to stay, but it's also clear they didn't replace classic controls. Devs should choose the best controls for each game or offer users the choice whenever possible, sensible and feasible, without surrendering to any other pressures than their own judgment and their users' tastes.

Edit: thinking again about it, devs could be right if they accept and seek ergonomics experts advice, but not marketing people, choosing the best controls for a game or any other program is the former's, not the latter's job.

both, like the Wiimote has

I really hope your wrong, but I have a niggling fear you might be right.

Next up : Vitality sensor as the REAL next gen controller - with .4 inch HD screen.

Getting rid of motion controls altogether would be downright foolish. It would be going backwards in technology. It'd be like getting rid of the joystick and trigger buttons. Motion controls are simply a natural evolution of the controller.

But at the same time, that doesn't mean they should be forced upon every single game, like Wii devs tried to do. Motion controls are only significant when the game is well suited for them, like Wii Sports, Mario Kart, etc. Just like people prefer not to play 2D Mario and Tetris with a joystick, certain games/genres are best left the way they are. I think Nintendo is starting to realize this, which is why they seem to be pushing a traditional type controller as well as a Wiimote for their next console.

as far as i know nintendo is planning to do a hybrid scheme with both control types supported... im pretty sure that that info was leaked already... i think i also read something about how nintendo was planning to implement a new motion controller thats supposed to be more accurate than the move... so if those rumours are true we may end up with both controls being bundled with the console like how sony does currently