How so, if the handheld Zeldas are craped with gimicks and puzzles as well? The Zelda series will never expand if they continue thinking like you. Not only that. that stupid Zelda Wii is taking Nintendo their biggest amount of resources and persons working at it ever, and it is just going to be an average Zelda. Instead, they could be making a much higher quality, best seller old school Zelda, with much less resources and people working at it.

First of all, YES!  If anything will get me back into pokemon it could be this.

Second I would love to see something like an Elder Scrolls style of an MMO.  I'm tired of the auto-attack, hit ability A, wait for cooldown, etc.  Make boss fights and raids more dynamic so that the enemy can't be planned down to a statistical analysis of what to do after a certain milestone is achieved.

And Zelda will fail if they think like you and make it just another combat game. We have enough of those out there.

I'm not surprised you think this way, since the Zelda fanbase is so divided and think their way is the best way for the series. No one Zelda game will everf ully satisfy all the fans.

I don't know a single decent game out there that uses Motion plus for combat like Zelda could. It would be the best Zleda game made. But Nintendo just doesn't want to do it, they prefer to make puzzles because those are easy to develop.

Half to the Life 3. And Counter-Strike 2, and another completely competive socom or better yet socom collection

I'd love to see a Scrooge McDuck game. He's by far the most fleshed out Duckburg character and deserves a video game or two.

Edit:

A S. McDuck game inspired by Epic Mickey and the McDuck comic "The dream of a lifetime" would be awsome.

Godhand 2!!!!!

a Zak Mackracken Remake with the Uncharted Charackters and Engine

I wish there was an unbugged Fallout game for once....

This could work in an alternate reality or a different planet as the actions could then be labeled as moral somehow.