yep the percentage of console fans on this site heavily favors PS3. So any pole like this is just a joke. In reality though gears is a way better game.

So basically, A majority of people that voted for uncharted never played gears or even seen it. What a joke. Should be a 3rd vote for, can't make a honest vote.

Gears 3 wouldn't even win against Lair (which I admit I haven't played, either).  No big deal.  At least the arguments in this thread seemed a lot more balanced.  There's nothing wrong with people liking Uncharted 3 more.  From the trailer, it looks like a top notch thread.  It's just the feeling that Gears never even had a fair chance that irks me.

really, tell me more.

i would definitely choose gears over lair, i dont even really know what lair is. (i think its some kind of dragon games. is it ps3 exclusive?)

MORE!

uncharted 2 most awarded game of all time enough said. Gears of war not sure but I heard it lags like balls in the mp, and has shit story compared to uncharted 2

really Gears is a better game? How so? Uncharted is superior in almost every way.  Graphics, Pacing, Story, Characters, and much more diverse gameplay. The only thing Gears has over uncharted is more gore. Uncharted is a MUCH more deep single player experience. Many people call uncharted 2 the best game of all time, and to be honest uncharted 2 is the only game this gen that deserves that high of a honor. Maybe Mgs4.

Fixed.

It's personal preference, dude.