Kantor said:
Doobie_wop said:
- The site has to become more lenient on it's members. Members should be allowed to come in and give a strong opinion about something, without the fear of getting banned because it might hurt the feelings of a few fanboys. The reason why Neogaf is such a great place for discussion is because actual debate is allowed and the mods don't care for the feelings of their more sensitive members. Sometimes a VGChartz thread really hits the right note and a long 30 page discussion takes place and it's actually interesting, but most of the time they hit a brick at the 4th page because everyone's too scared to keep going on. Trolls should be banned, but I believe there is a difference between a trollish remark and a strong opinion. Also, I should be able to swear whenever I want. I don't have to swear at other people to insult them, but I shouldn't have to feel guilty about saying 'fuckin Nintendo' when I'm having a rant as to why a new F-Zero hasn't been made.
Anyway, that's my thoughts. Enjoy.
|
Did you just say gamrConnect moderation is harsh while praising the leniency of NeoGAF mods?
This thread confuses me greatly.
|
Neogaf mods ban people for stupid things, but it isn't frequent and they do allow a large amount of freedom in what you can post. As an example, if I was a dick to Evilore and continued to post stupid stuff about him or thing's he just doesn't generally like (which isn't a part of the rules) he'll ban me. The same thing applies to all the mods on that site. What makes the discussions good is that I can be extremely negative about a product, argue against people about their opinion on that product and pretty much say whatever I want, just as long as it isn't false or spamming.
I find that on VGChartz, the mods have a 'please everyone' mentality, which is wrong, because some people are far too sensitive to negativity and debate and so this leads to short threads and a lack of proper discussion. This has been my experience.