Mass Effect 2 by far.....

I haven't decided yet actually. One of them:

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
Fallout New Vegas
Red Dead Redemption
Mass Effect 2
Final Fantasy XIII
Halo Reach

If it wasn't for the bugs, I would've gone with Fallout New Vegas immediately, but they really damped my enjoyment a bit.

If CGI asks me, it's Heavy Rain.

If darth asks me, it's FFXIII.

But because it's you Zucas, I'm going to say Red Dead Redemption.

I'm an hypocrite!

For me it's tough, SMG2, Golden Sun, Other M, Red Dead Redemption/undead nightmare, Bayonetta, No More Heroes 2, Tatsunoko vs Capcom, Fallout New Vegas, DKCR, Kingdom Hearts BBS, Super Scribblenauts, and Golden Eye are all my favorite games this year, and by their own rights should have a GOTY award somewhere... 

It's really hard to narrow these down but if I had to it'd be between SMG2, DKCR, Bayonetta, and RDR.

Out of those I hope I'm not giving it a nod because of playing it after SMG2 and Bayonetta, but DKCR gets my favorite game of the year vote.

Donkey Kong.

Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep.

The game showed me square still has the magic, just on handhelds now.

Prince of Persia

 under cabinet TV 

 audiovox under cabinet tv

Monster Hunter Tri (Wii)

Sengoku Basara: Samurai Heroes (Wii)

Call Of Duty: Black Ops (Wii)

Oh shit I totally forgot to list MH3 on my post, thats probably the game I actually spent the most time on out of all the games on my list lol but thats because if you want anything in the game you have to.

Mass Effect 2

Comic Jumper