I just replayed inFamous and I'm gonna replay Uncharted. Then I got to thinking, which is better. I think I like Uncharted 1 better but I can't remember because it was so long ago. I'm gonna replay it now.

EDIT: I'm talking about Uncharted 1 people. Of course, U2 blows the socks off inFamous

Gameplaywise i say Infamous, but Infamous had downright awkward character animations.

inFamous for me. One of the best gameplay mechanic this gen.

Uncharted is great. The first game where i really felt like trying for a Platinum throphy, and i got it. I've played through it 5 times. But when i played inFamous i was soo much fun and im a sucker for a good singleplayer story, and that game was pure awesomesauce.

Its hard to chose. If i break it down to sections like Gameplay, Story, Graphics etc... inFamous would probably take the top spot, but Uncharted has that little extra which makes it such a great game. Hands down, those are the only two franchises i will get day one. No other game franchise has me so hyped for sequals.. except for Demon's Souls maybe(!)

I bought inFamous the Friday of the week it came out.  To this day, I haven't finished it.  It was kinda "bleh" to me.  Now Uncharted (and it's sequel) kept me hooked from beginning to end.  I gotta hang with Drake.

InFamous is funner

Believe me, there is some point in the game (a plot twist) where it will change everything and becomes very interesting,it will be hard to let it down till you know whats what, i know what you are feeling right now, i've had that when i stopped playing it (came back later)

infamous > Uncharted

They're both alright so play for trophies

They are really just too different to compare and they are both amazing. But for me I get sucked into the Treasure hunter mystery experience in Uncharted and I can't wait for Drake's next adventure.