I think random first day lynches are a bad idea, odds are in the town's disfavor (17 people 4-6 mafia/SK, that means at least 4-6 votes directed thowards a random townie on which people will bandwaggon)
So I'm scummy ? GTFO.
Your post was rings waaay more alarms. Lets see -
The quote above is nonsensical.
Theres a very high chance of a player dying on night one. One player. Maybe 2 max. The odds of hitting mafia today and the odds of hitting mafia tomorrow will be pretty much the same.
As I pointed out in the last game, ironically, the town won for the first time in a long while in the DBZ game where we did a day one mislynch lead by me (though that was 90% Kamal's fault). We were going for a SK before him (radishhead).
We lynch someone today. If we're lucky, we hit scum. If not, then thats 1 less player to worry about...we don't have to figure out whether he is pro or anti town any more.
My vote on Final fan was a joke vote btw... And I'm not suggesting we randomly lynch people. I'm suggesting that we discuss stuff, like we are doing right now, and get a read on people. The person whom we think is the scummiest after a day or two of discussion gets lynched.
However I think First day, first page calls for a lynch are just plain scummy, GoW. Adding to this that you're very likely to be using the fact that in the past 2 games you had a power role and went on a first day voting spree as a shield against suspicion.... I doubt you'd do it again as town since it got you killed night one both times ^^.
Major HoS on GoWand what's with the free agressivity?
I want a day one lynch. How the hell is that scummy ? Aggressive maybe. But the people who are over-protective about day one lynches are the people who are scummy imo.
On the DBZ game, I roleclaimed Goku. I was killed because there was a Mafia assassin who could bypass doctor's protection.
On the sailor moon game I genuinely slipped up...which is partly the fault of you and theprof's insanity. But lets not go there.
This will be my style of play from now on...eventually the scumbags would get sick of killing me, no ?
There is nothing wrong with being aggressive...but I'm sick of people being scared about the day one lynches. Its a gamble that'll pay off very nicely if it works out.