By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - God Didn't Create Universe

Smidlee said:
FaRmLaNd said:
GameOver22 said:

If God is unnecessary, God would be eliminated by Ockham's razor. There would be no reason to posture God if the universe was completely explained in scientific terms. For this reasons, theists would not accept the idea of an unnecessary God.

Well thats been the case for a long time and doesn't really require science to point that out. Its as simple as this. Many theists say something can't come from nothing. But where did God come from? He always existed or created himself or whatever way you want to spin it. Thats a double standard. If God can come from nothing or always existed, why not just skip a step and apply that to the universe. Why does God get some kind of special status? If something can come from nothing, then surely other things can. Such as the Universe? Why regress to God?

It's the first law of  thermodynamics that states something can't come from nothing. If something did come from nothing then  it's  greater than the law of thermodynamics(as well as  human understanding). 

We have strong reason to believe  the universe contains intelligence and creators. ;)

Expain to me how something coming from nothing is greater then human understanding. I have't read his book, but if Hawking is talking about how it may well be possible for the universe to create itself from nothing without the aid of God then how is that greater then human understanding, if science is starting to speculate on something coming from nothing?

I will acknowledge that we simply don't know enough about it and most of this is very theoretical and thus is on the fringes of human understanding and may remain that way for a long time. But why is it "greater" then human understandings?



Around the Network
MrBubbles said:

Just because we, as humans, cant comprehend something doesnt mean it isnt true.  We are very limited beings.  Your options are: everything/something came from nothing, or everything/something always existed......or you got some unknown unknowns which are pointless to discuss since they are unknown.

I can basically say the sam thing to someone who believes that something can't come from nothing. In the end it's all just presumptions.



"I don't understand how someone could like Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, but not like Twilight!!!"

"Last book I read was Brokeback Mountain, I just don't have the patience for them unless it's softcore porn."

                                                                               (The Voice of a Generation and Seece)

"If you cant stand the sound of your own voice than dont become a singer !!!!!"

                                                                               (pizzahut451)

sapphi_snake said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

Mankind also didn't believe in your god (or any deity for that matter) since it's creation either.

they believed in higher power, that was my point. I never said they believed in christian God



highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

How about things people used to believe in then? Apollo, Thor, Ra, Gaia, Odin, Athena, etc. These aren't believable now, and yet people used to believe in them on a grand scale.


those were all Gods. And tooth fairy is not a God. So you cant comapre tooth fair to a god/gods. That list of yours only proves my point



pizzahut451 said:
highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

How about things people used to believe in then? Apollo, Thor, Ra, Gaia, Odin, Athena, etc. These aren't believable now, and yet people used to believe in them on a grand scale.


those were all Gods. And tooth fairy is not a God. So you cant comapre tooth fair to a god/gods. That list of yours only proves my point

I know they're all gods. I only provided that list because you deemed the tooth fairy a bad example because nobody ever believed in it (which is something I would argue as millions of kids believe in the tooth fairy, like adults worldwide believe in god(s)), so I gave a list of gods which are now considered mythical. I thought maybe it was a more appropriate example than the tooth fairy

All the examples I gave were once believed in by people as much as god, but are now considered mythical. I think it fits in well with Serious frusting's statement and the criteria you deemed to be acceptable if I just replace the tooth fairy with one of those examples...

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as Thor"

Thor is unbelievable, but you said that no-one ever believed in the tooth fairy and that was the reason it wasn't valid. People used to believe in Thor but don't now, so now it keeps SF's original idea, but conforms to your criteria of having to have once been believed in too.

Either way then, if you want a non god example, how about dragons? People were convinced that dragons existed, but now they're considered mythical.

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as dragons"

But to be brutally honest you're just moving the goalposts because both Thor and the tooth fairy are valid examples. 



Around the Network
pizzahut451 said:
highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

How about things people used to believe in then? Apollo, Thor, Ra, Gaia, Odin, Athena, etc. These aren't believable now, and yet people used to believe in them on a grand scale.


those were all Gods. And tooth fairy is not a God. So you cant comapre tooth fair to a god/gods. That list of yours only proves my point

I know they're all gods. I only provided that list because you deemed the tooth fairy a bad example because nobody ever believed in it (which is something I would argue as millions of kids believe in the tooth fairy, like adults worldwide believe in god(s)), so I gave a list of gods which are now considered mythical. I thought maybe it was a more appropriate example than the tooth fairy

All the examples I gave were once believed in by people as much as god, but are now considered mythical. I think it fits in well with Serious frusting's statement and the criteria you deemed to be acceptable if I just replace the tooth fairy with one of those examples...

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as Thor"

Thor is unbelievable, but you said that no-one ever believed in the tooth fairy and that was the reason it wasn't valid. People used to believe in Thor but don't now, so now it keeps SF's original idea, but conforms to your criteria of having to have once been believed in too.

Either way, if you want a non god example, how about dragons? People were convinced that dragons existed, but now they're considered mythical.

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as dragons"

But to be brutally honest you're just moving the goalposts because both Thor and the tooth fairy are valid examples. 



pizzahut451 said:
highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

How about things people used to believe in then? Apollo, Thor, Ra, Gaia, Odin, Athena, etc. These aren't believable now, and yet people used to believe in them on a grand scale.


those were all Gods. And tooth fairy is not a God. So you cant comapre tooth fair to a god/gods. That list of yours only proves my point

I know they're all gods. I only provided that list because you deemed the tooth fairy a bad example because nobody ever believed in it*, so I gave a short list of gods which are now considered mythical. I thought maybe it was a more appropriate example than the tooth fairy

All the examples I gave were once believed in by people as much as god, but are now considered mythical. I think it fits in well with Serious frusting's statement and the criteria you deemed to be acceptable if I just replace the tooth fairy with one of those examples...

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as Thor"

People used to believe in Thor but don't now, so now it keeps SF's original idea, but conforms to your criteria of having to have once been believed in too.

Either way, if you want a non god example, how about dragons? People were convinced that dragons existed, but now they're considered mythical.

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as dragons"

But to be brutally honest you're just moving the goalposts because both Thor and the tooth fairy are valid examples. 

(*which is something I would argue as millions of kids believe in the tooth fairy, like adults worldwide believe in god(s))



I'll just add who created this gravity, time, mass and objects, even energy?  Who created nothingneess for something to come from? For there to be nothing didn't there have to be something first? I love science, but trying to use it to disprove religion just will not work, religion is a belief, not a fact. Hell who/what created the rules in wich nature operates. AS someone already said this adds nothing to the argument of who or what if anything created it all.



highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
highwaystar101 said:
pizzahut451 said:
Serious_frusting said:

Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as the tooth fairy


except that the mankind didnt believe in the tooth fairy since its creation...

How about things people used to believe in then? Apollo, Thor, Ra, Gaia, Odin, Athena, etc. These aren't believable now, and yet people used to believe in them on a grand scale.


those were all Gods. And tooth fairy is not a God. So you cant comapre tooth fair to a god/gods. That list of yours only proves my point

I know they're all gods. I only provided that list because you deemed the tooth fairy a bad example because nobody ever believed in it*, so I gave a short list of gods which are now considered mythical. I thought maybe it was a more appropriate example than the tooth fairy

All the examples I gave were once believed in by people as much as god, but are now considered mythical. I think it fits in well with Serious frusting's statement and the criteria you deemed to be acceptable if I just replace the tooth fairy with one of those examples...

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as Thor"

People used to believe in Thor but don't now, so now it keeps SF's original idea, but conforms to your criteria of having to have once been believed in too.

Either way, if you want a non god example, how about dragons? People were convinced that dragons existed, but now they're considered mythical.

"Why are people so hung up on religion in these forums. In my opinion anything to do with god is as believable as dragons"

But to be brutally honest you're just moving the goalposts because both Thor and the tooth fairy are valid examples. 

(*which is something I would argue as millions of kids believe in the tooth fairy, like adults worldwide believe in god(s))

How many chemicals have science at one time said to be safe, only later to be proven harmful? How many times have science been used incorrectly and thrown out as fact? Science is just as bad as getting it wrong. Until science can start making advances without mistakes I will not take scietific "facts" as gospel. I prefer to wait till they can actually fully explain what they propose, until then its just theory, as so much religion is.



thranx said:

How many chemicals have science at one time said to be safe, only later to be proven harmful? How many times have science been used incorrectly and thrown out as fact? Science is just as bad as getting it wrong. Until science can start making advances without mistakes I will not take scietific "facts" as gospel. I prefer to wait till they can actually fully explain what they propose, until then its just theory, as so much religion is.

Religion isn't a theory, as it doesn't aim to prove anything, but assumes that what is says is fact. The beauty of science is that it corrects itself.



"I don't understand how someone could like Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, but not like Twilight!!!"

"Last book I read was Brokeback Mountain, I just don't have the patience for them unless it's softcore porn."

                                                                               (The Voice of a Generation and Seece)

"If you cant stand the sound of your own voice than dont become a singer !!!!!"

                                                                               (pizzahut451)