dunno001 said:
c0rd said:
dunno001 said: Yes, FF needs to return to its roots. It's being hit-and-miss on games since about FF8, but staying to ones base can result in a strong and loyal fanbase; look at their own Dragon Quest series as an example. Regarding FF13, to FF standards, it's a miss. FF13 will be the worst selling mainline FF in Japan since FF4! The verdict on worldwide is still out, but it looks to definitely be in the lower half of sales in the Playstation era. |
Not really fair to blame the game itself entirely for its sales, you need to consider the platform it's on. Even if the game were a "hit," it'd have trouble selling.
|
*kicks computer* I was typing up a nice long reply to this when it decided to hang, so I don't feel like redoing it all. I'll sum it up, though.
Look at the Japanese sales of system launch FF games to the system's install bases in Japan, and you will find ratios well over 50%. (This is true with FF4, 7, and 10.) Then look at FF13. It's going to struggle to reach that 50%, if it even does. It's not selling nearly as well even on an install base ratio. The difference between PS1 (the highest console install number) at FF7 launch and PS3 at FF13 launch is less than 1 million. So why, then, does it look like FF13 will be about a million behind FF10, and considerably more behind FF7. It can only mean that it is not selling as well, and this is irregardless of the system. Unless you're trying to say it would have sold better on the Wii, which I would dispute, because it was the PS era that made the game all about graphics and FMVs, something that the PS3 could do better, and the current targeted fanbase would expect.
|
Alright, since I have time, my explanation of why FFXIII itself may not be the cause of decline:
Install base. I don't mean the number itself, as that doesn't tell us the whole story. Perhaps some previous FF fans decided to skip this gen out for the Wii, as it has the bigger RPG coming for it, Dragon Quest. This is really the first time the two franchises were put on separate consoles, it's possible that many fans of both (which should be large, I imagine there's a big overlap) can't afford two, three, maybe four consoles. There's no way all fans of Square Enix can afford all the consoles they're supporting on the market at the moment (DS, PSP, Wii, PS3), so sales will have to suffer somewhere.
FF is a long running series. Ever since FFV, most people buy it first week. This means that a large portion of its sales are dependent on things like overall interest in the series, the reception of the previous game, stuff like that - most of which have little to do with the game itself. It's not unlike Hollywood blockbusters - the biggest openings always come from sequels of well-received movies. Besides, the fact that there has been a decline in the series ever since FFVIII means you couldn't solely put the blame on FFXIII, but other games as well, like FFIX, FFX.
As for being a million behind FFX, that's mainly due to re-releases and such. From the other thread:
Final Fantasy X --- 2,323,463
Final Fantasy X International --- 240,940
Final Fantasy X (Mega Hits!) --- 199,429
Final Fantasy X (Ultimate Hits) --- 179,959
Final Fantasy X International (ULTIMATE) --- 47,676
Final Fantasy X/X-2 (Ultimate Hits) --- 25,784
Total --- 3,017,251.
Admittedly, FFXIII's extra releases won't see numbers quite like this, but that's where I pull the userbase excuse (keke), as the PS2 had really taken off by then.
Anyway, I know there's a problem with FF, seeing its decline, though I wouldn't say FFXIII is any more a failure than FFX (looking at sales). There's just no easy solution for the franchise. The problem with focusing on Japanese sales is that the majority of sales come from outside the country. I'm a huge fan of older FF's, but would they sell as well in the west? Just what would a modern day FF look like if it returned to its roots, anyway?