Raistline said:
slowmo said:
Raistline said:
slowmo said:
Raistline said:
slowmo said:
Herbie95 said:
XBox exclusives are mostly fps's. But Nintendo and Sony have much more variety. |
Viva Pinata, Viva Pinata Trouble In Paradise, Forza 2 & 3, PGR 3 & 4, Banjo Kazooie N&B, Blue Dragon, Fable II, Gears 1 & 2 (Third Person Shooter), Halo Wars, Lost Odyssey, Mass Effect 1 & 2, Ninja Blade, Race Pro, Scene It 1 & 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Alan Wake, Dead Rising, Crackdown.
Thats just a start but there is loads of others too that aren't FPS. I'm guessing you don't have a 360 so you have no idea of how varied the software is, its just easy to copy every other troll and call it the shooter box.
|
I don't think that anyone denies that the Xbox360 has games other then shooters. But the major question is, which games are really successful on the 360 that are not shooters.
To give a PS2 analogue, there is Katamari, Ico and for the PS3 there is LBP, Ratchet and clank and GoW3.
I just can't think of any really successful 360 games that are not shooters, other then FFXIII or Forza.
|
I can list at least 10, some are listed in the quote I gave you. Since when did a game have to sell x amount to be considered whether it exists for the purposes of a debate. My point is quite clear that he said most 360 exclusives are FPS's, that is a lie, he is wrong, there really is no debate regarding that fact.
If you want to get on the variety fact and what sells then in all honesty I wouldn't be a poster child for the PS3's variety of sales as its got its fair share of problems shifting software other than the traditional hardcore market. If you say Nintendo have more variety there is a huge amount of gamers not being serviced or happy with what Nintendo is providing on the Wii too. The PS3 doesn't have anywhere near the variety of the PS2 and never will as its been marketed to a older crowd, pure and simple.
|
I did not at all say that a game has to sell X amount to be considered whether it exists or not. As I already stated, no one denies that Xbox360 has variety. I simply believe that most people will argue that the games of different varieties are no where near as successful as the shooter genre.
You do not see the same thing when it comes to PS3, Wii, PS3, or any other console to even close to the same degree as you see it on the Xbox360. This is why the Xbox360 has been pegged as the shooter box. It just does not have a sizeable list of non shooter games that have been succesful.
I also never said that the PS3 nor Wii had a great amount of successful variety either. The Wii is famous for mini-game games and prime nintendo franchises. The PS3 is known for Blu-Ray more then any one genre. Each conosle has thier niche.
Finally, for all the xbox exclusives that come to mind that are really successful and not shooter games, I can still only think of Forza. Fable, and maybe Mass Effect, but that is kind of a rpg/shooter.
I will say again, most successfull games on the Xbox 360 (a system is generally known by it successfull games and not it's semi-successful games) are in the vast majorty shooters of one type or another. The same cannot be said for either of the 2 current gen systems.
|
I entered the debate disagreeing with a guy who said 360 exclusives are mostly FPS's, he was wrong. You then quoted me and tried to make out I said something in error, which I didn't.
It doesn't matter how successful the different varieties are, they're available on the console so my point that there is variety is more than justified. I'm not arguing perceptions with you, there is no point as its purely subjective, the facts of the matter is that most 360 exclusives are NOT FPS games, it really isn't such a hard concept to grasp and its concrete fact not opinions.
|
I guess we are discussing two different points then. I am leaning towards how the perception of Xbox360 as a shooter box because the majority of it's hit titles are shooters and the success of the hit titles for a system usually defines the system in the eyes of the public.
Your point is true that not all exclusives are FPS's. I was just trying to give a different side of the story as to why many peole think that it is so. I was not arguing with you directly nor trying to prove you wrong, just looking at it from a different angle. No need to be in a huff about it.
Last point, I never once said that 360 exclusives are all FPS's, I fully grasp that it has a wider variety in it's library then that. You are putting me in a category to which I do not fit by your last statement.
|
