1. Final Fantasy IV DS
2. Elite Beat Agents
3. The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks

1. Mario & Luigi: Bower's Inside Story
2. Kingdom Hearts: 358/2 Days
3. Pokemon Platinum

1.- Jump Ultimate Stars
2.- Pokemon Platinum
3.- Mario Kart DS

Honor Mention:

Mario & Luigi: Bowser´s Inside Story
New Super Mario Bros DS
Pokemon HeartGold(It will be)

1) Chrono Trigger DS
2) Star Fox Command
3) Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass

1 - Animal Crossing
2 - Elite Beat Agents
3 - Probably will be taken by Pokemon Heartgold.

1. New Super Mario Brothers

2. Animal Crossing

3. Pac 'n' Roll (and probably the only vote it will get, but I loved it)

Oooh... hard decision...

1 - Scribblenauts
2 - Mario Kart DS
3 - Metroid Prime: Hunters

1- Hotel Dusk
2- Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
3- Dragon Quest IV

We will revisit this at a later time.