Disappointment of course implies unfulfilled promises, in which case this is a pretty good list (though a rather unknown first choice).

Spore is notably absent.

nah , there are bigger games than these. too human is one of them (at least to the devs).

Plus MGS2 is a great game, heck one of the best on the PS2. but the reviewers just had to bitch about it cause of changed character.

MGS2? It may be my least favorite MGS game but it was still damn good!

@Twest , When they say disappointing, they don't mean bad.

WTF!! I'm pissed!! Where is Confrontation!!! LOL..

GTA4...
Too Human...


But they chose... Metal Gear Solid 2?

Oh my.

I thought most people absolutely loved Doom 3? o.O

MGS2 was very good imo..

not MGS3 OR MGS4 or MGS

but still amazingly good, had a great emotional connection with each character imo

No Nintendo games!!

Although I did see Luigi's Mansion in the preview!

I didn't. I actually found it quite boring.